Stencil Your Way to a Stunning Cement Tile Tray

Beautiful and timelssly on-trend, cement tile adds a big punch of color and pattern to any room — but it's pricey ... and heavy. Get the same luxe look without the hefty price tag (and, well, heft!) by stenciling a board to create a gorgeous tray.

Photo by: Sarah Busby; Styling by H. Camille Smith

Sarah Busby; Styling by H. Camille Smith

Materials Needed

  • 3/4" board, cut to 16" x 32" (Tip: Have it cut at your local hardware store)
  • 1/4" wood lattice, 2 pieces each: cut to 15-3/4" x 32-1/2" (Tip: Have it cut at your local hardware store)
  • cream matte craft or latex paint
  • blue-gray matte craft or latex paint
  • chip brush
  • medium- and fine-grit sandpaper
  • cement tile stencil
  • stencil brush
  • heavy-duty staple gun (or tack nails and hammer)
  • matte or satin water-based polyurethane
  • wood putty
  • painter's tape
  • paper towels
  • ruler and pencil

Sand Board and Side Pieces

Using first medium- then fine-grit sandpaper, smooth the board's cut edges and any surface roughness. Keep in mind that you're replicating the look of cement tile, which is smooth, so also fill in any knotholes or dents in the wood.

Photo by: Sarah Busby

Sarah Busby

Paint Board With Base Color

Give the board a solid coat of cream paint and allow to thoroughly dry. This color will be the base color of your stenciled tiles. Tip: Cement tile often has a slightly mottled color so one thick coat will be sufflicient.

Photo by: Sarah Busby

Sarah Busby

Mark Board's Center

First, find and mark the board's lengthwise center (Image 1). Draw a light pencil line for reference (Image 2). Note: This is where you'll begin stenciling so the finished pattern will be centered.

Stencil First Tile

Center the stencil over the pencil line and use painter's tape to prevent it from shifting (Image 1). Pour a small amount of paint into a shallow dish and lightly — more isn't better — load up the stencil brush (Image 2). Starting in the center of the tile, and working your way out to the edges, use a straight up-and-down pouncing motion to apply paint to the stencil (Image 3). Carefully remove the stencil to reveal the painted pattern — ta da! (Image 4).

Clean Back and Edges of Stencil

To prevent transferring errant paint smears as you stencil the second tile, flip the stencil over and use a damp paper towel to clean off any leaked paint. Tip: This is why it's important to use minimal paint when stenciling; some will always leak thru but light paint application helps to minimize it. Also, clean 2 sides of the stencil's front so you can see through the plastic to better line up the pattern's repeat.

Photo by: Sarah Busby

Sarah Busby

Continue Stenciling

Allow the first tile's paint to fully dry (usually just a few minutes) then using one of the sides you've cleaned for reference, line up the stencil for the second tile. Tip: Use the stencil's repeat (an area you painted previously) to help you line up the stencil (Image 1). Secure the edges with painter's tape (Image 2), then lightly load up the stencil brush and repeat the straight up-and-down pouncing motion to paint the second tile. Continue stenciling, following the steps of cleaning the stencil's back and front between tiles and only working next to dried tiles, till the entire board is covered.

Paint Lattice Strips

Using a chip brush and matte latex or acrylic paint, coat the pre-cut lattice strips on all sides and allow to dry.

Photo by: Sarah Busby

Sarah Busby

Add Tray's Sides

Position the tray's sides: 2 shorter lattice strips on the 16" side and 2 longer lattice strips on the 32" side to create a simple butt joint. Use painter's tape on each end to secure the trim as you attach it using a staple gun (Image 1) or nails and a hammer. Fill the nail or staple holes with wood putty (Image 2) and allow to dry. Sand any excess dried putty (Image 3), then touch up the paint on the tray's sides (Image 4). Finally, protect the painted surface with a coat of polyurethane.

Thoroughly Wash Stencil

Place the stencil (as flat as possible) in the kitchen sink and clean using dish soap and water, being careful not to twist or tear the stencil. Allow it to fully dry, then store between 2 sheets of cardboard or in a flat location so it can be used again.

Photo by: Sarah Busby

Sarah Busby

Display Your Cement Tile Lookalike Tray

Perfect for stylishly corraling remotes on your coffee table and lightweight enough that you can use it for serving drinks, this tray is a stunner you'll want to use in any room of your home.

Next Up

How to Paint & Stencil Ceramic Tile

Remodeling on a budget? Give outdated floors a refresh with our step-by-step guide to painting and stenciling ceramic tile. All you need are a few basic supplies and a free weekend to totally transform the look of a laundry room, bathroom or other place in your home that's plagued by old or dirty tile. The best part? You can do it all for less than $75 and without special equipment.

DIY Concrete Vintage Camper Planter

Vacation starts now. Your plants can hit the road and see the sights in style in this vintage-inspired concrete camper.

No Sunlight Needed: These Vibrant Houseplants Are Actually Made From Paper

If you love indoor plants but lack natural light or the time to properly care for them, Corrie Beth Hogg, expert crafter and author of Handmade Houseplants: Remarkably Realistic Plants You Can Make with Paper, shares a paper plant DIY perfect for adding a faux green-thumb vibe to any living space.

Ice Tie-Dye Napkins Four Ways

A tie-dye DIY so simple it only takes three ingredients: powder fabric dye, cotton napkins and ice.

3 Easy Wooden Bangle Crafts

Pick up a pack of assorted wooden bangles and dive into this trendy DIY.

DIY Paper Chain Wall Art

We’re bringing back the humble paper chain, but this time we’re turning it into an Instagram-worthy wall hanging.

Craft a Clay Incense House Burner

Keep your house smelling oh-so-fresh all season long by crafting an incense-burning house out of oven-bake clay.

How to Make a Giant Christmas Stocking

Switch things up this holiday season by replacing the traditional wreath on your front door with an oversized stocking. This DIY giant Christmas stocking is the perfect addition to your seasonal decor and can be made with just a few basic craft supplies.

Make This Stylish, Acrylic Bird Feeder With Midcentury Flair

Let all the neighborhood birds know the perfect place to hang out.

Three Ways to Make Easy Paper Flowers

All you need is cheap party streamers to make these gorgeous flowers.

What's New in Handmade

On TV

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.