Charcoal vs. Gas: Outdoor Grills

It's the most important feature in an outdoor kitchen, but before you go shopping for a grill make sure you've done your research.

Outdoor Great Room Kitchen Grill Closed

By: Amanda Lecky

As the popularity of outdoor kitchens has grown in recent years manufacturers have introduced a manner of outdoor appliances, from wine refrigerators to built-in deep fryers. Chances are you just need a great grill.

Don't rush into buying a grill. It's the most important feature of your outdoor kitchen, and a good place to invest a big chunk of your budget. To decide which grill is right for you, keep these considerations in mind.

CI-Masterbuilt_outdoor-grill_s3x4

Charcoal Grill

Charcoal Grill

CI-Cal-Flame_grill_s3x4

Gas Grill

Gas Grill

Gas or Charcoal?

Gas grills are convenient, they ignite at the push of a button and allow you to control the heat with the turn of a knob, but they're not ideal for true slow-cooked barbecue. Charcoal grills burn hotter than gas grills and you can burn wood in a charcoal grill, to impart a natural, smoky flavor to your foods. But it's harder to control the temperature, you have to stoke the fire constantly, and at the end of cooking you're left with a mess of ashes.

So which type to choose? Maybe both: a gas grill for everyday grilling, and a charcoal model for more occasional barbecuing. Or if your budget is ample, look for a grill that offers both options in one unit. Electric grills are another choice, and may be the only option for apartment or condo dwellers, but they don't impart a real barbecue flavor.

Gas Grills

Once you've settled on your grill, you'll have a few more decisions to make.

Materials

Most grills are made from cast aluminum, sheet metal, cast iron or stainless steel. Stainless steel is the best (and priciest) choice because it holds up well to the elements over time. It may be tempting to save some money by starting out with a less expensive grill that you can upgrade later, but that's not always a smart strategy, particularly if the grill is built-in.

"There's no standard grill size," says Mark Allen, president of the National Outdoor Kitchen and Fireplace Association. "If your cheap grill doesn't last and you have to replace it, you'll probably have to redo the opening in the counter, which can be a big headache." Instead, he advises choosing a mid-range grill made of high-quality materials.

Size

Gas grills are measured by the number of square inches of cooking surface they provide. Inexpensive grills start around 500 square inches, and a high-end gas grill may offer several times that capacity. Find the right size for your needs by evaluating your cooking habits. If you regularly cook for a crowd, you may want a large grill with multiple burners and a smaller surface with three burners is fine for meals for a family of four.

Power

Grill power is measured in British Thermal Units (Btus). A small grill may have about 40,000 Btus or fewer, while a large grill may have as many as 100,000 Btus of power. Look for grill power someplace in the middle.

Accessories

As you might expect, the higher the price of the grill, the more bells and whistles—like side burners, infrared searing stations, rotisseries, dual-fuel functionality, and smoking compartments—it's likely to feature. Again, look to your habits to decide which features are worth your money.

Generally speaking, it's smart to choose a grill with at least two separately controlled burners so you can grill foods indirectly (a technique often used for cooking larger items like whole chickens), a built-in temperature gauge, and a gas gauge, so you won't run out of propane mid-meal.

Charcoal Grills

There are more types of charcoal grills than gas grills. You'll find kettle grills, built-in grills, table grills, hibachis, barrel smokers, water smokers and ceramic cookers, all of which use charcoal to grill or barbecue foods.

The right one for you will depend on how you like to cook, but whichever charcoal grill suits your style, look for these signs of quality:

  • Sturdy, high-grade steel construction
  • A tightly fitting lid
  • Baked-on porcelain enamel finish for a kettle grillHeat-resistant handles
  • Vents on the top and bottom for adjusting temperature
  • A hinged cooking grate, which makes it easier to add coals to the fire

Next Up

How to Budget for an Outdoor Kitchen

Creating a complete outdoor cooking space can be expensive, but you can still put together a great outdoor kitchen without spending a fortune. Learn how to find a balance between what you want and what you can afford.

Outdoor Kitchen Countertops Ideas

There are several options for outdoor kitchen countertops — natural stone, concrete and tile are the most popular.  What you choose should depend on your budget, climate and your particular backyard.

How to Turn a Utility Cart Into a Patio Grill Station

Learn how to trick out a metal cart with a wood top, magnetic hooks and baskets so it can be used as a portable outdoor kitchen island or bar.

The 10 Best Dishwashers for Every Budget in 2023

If it's time to buy a new dishwasher, read this 101 guide first.

How to Remove a Garbage Disposal

Removing a garbage disposal may seem intimidating, but it's a deceptively easy DIY job.

How to Remove a Dishwasher

Removing your dishwasher doesn't need to be left to the pros. Follow our steps to get the dishwasher out yourself in no time.

How to Plan and Build an Outdoor Kitchen

Aesthetics are important but when it comes to building an outdoor kitchen, functionality and durability reign supreme. Read our professional tips to budget, plan and design an outdoor kitchen that will add value to your home and lifestyle.

How to Build a Grilling Island

Create an outdoor kitchen by nestling a gas grill into a custom-built, granite-topped island.

An Outdoor Kitchen Dream Come True

In this Austin, TX, house, the main ingredient is the Latin American-inspired cookspace that opens to the backyard.

Why is My Dishwasher Not Draining?

Notice standing water in the bottom of the dishwasher? Learn how to diagnose, troubleshoot and perform simple repairs to fix it.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

On TV

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.