What We Love About Caraway’s Gorgeous Bakeware Collection

The colorful cookware company also has baking sheets and pans — and we want them all.

Sponsored: Our editors independently choose products they love from the sponsors’ product lines. Price and availability could change after publish date, and we may make money from these links.
Updated on November 21, 2023

I was reluctant to ditch dishwasher-friendly stainless steel cookware, but now that I’ve upgraded to Caraway’s non-stick ceramic I’m never going back. It’s worth the hand-washing, especially when food slides right off the pan. I can’t say the same for stainless steel. Our friends at Food Network even named it the best overall non-toxic cookware! Now that Caraway’s expanded to bakeware, I’m ready to say goodbye to cheap aluminum and glass, too. These pans and sheets are made of the same non-toxic, nonstick ceramic which means cakes, muffins and other notorious pan clingers will easily come out without a bunch of fake butter spray. Even better: The bakeware comes in fun colors, just like the cookware, which means they won't be an eyesore if you have open shelving. I LOVE my sage fry pan and Dutch oven, and now I can snag the exact same color in bakeware for a total matching set no matter what I’m whipping up in the kitchen. If you’re thinking about making the switch to ceramic bakeware, here’s why we’re big, big fans of Caraway. (Plus, get 10% off all Caraway cookware using our exclusive link.)

Who knew bakeware could be so pretty?! Cookie sheets, muffin pans and the like are usually stuffed and shoved into cabinets, but these pieces are so gorgeous that you'll want to display a muffin pan just as much as a cutting board or tea kettle. The colors are so good, from a deep, rich navy to the bright, perky marigold. And the neutrals are elevated, too, from a Scandi/Farmhouse cream to a "perracotta" that's perfect for serving brunch on the patio. These colors make something ordinary feel special, like a modern heirloom. Like an heirloom, if you take care of these pieces, they'll last for years and years.

Money-Saving Sets

Beyond the design, I love how customized you can get when shopping Caraway. Oftentimes, cookware and bakeware sets are massive, and who has room for a 20-piece gourmet pan set? No one. With Caraway, you can buy select bakeware a la carte to mix and match colors or snag the one item you really need. If you're not making cakes or cinnamon rolls weekly, you probably don't need a circle pan set. If you love meal prepping, it's nice to have a couple of baking sheets in different sizes.

However, if you're starting from scratch, the bakeware bundles — the full set or the half set are a great way to outfit your kitchen with the most important baking essentials without breaking the bank. The five-piece set is a great buy at under $300 for two sheets, one 9"x13" dish and a muffin pan. Plus, if you buy one of the sets, it comes with its own little storage caddy. Oh, yeah. It's a game-changer. The storage system maximizes each pan size so that pieces nest into each other and clear up more cabinet or counter space.

Colorful Baking Sheets

Like Caraway's cookware, the bakeware is oven-safe up to 550 degrees, which means toasting the top of casseroles, broiling meat or roasting veggies is no problem. The medium baking sheet is a great buy at under $50, and it's so versatile. Use it for Friday night cookies, meal-prepping veggies on Sunday and so much more.

Colorful Baking Pans

If you love cookouts and potlucks, say hello to your new favorite pans that double as beautiful serving dishes. The square pan is perfect for brownies, the rectangle is the prettiest 9"x13" casserole dish we've ever seen and this loaf pan is the perfect vessel for sending banana bread to a neighbor. Just remember to use wooden or silicone serving utensils, as metal spoons will scratch the ceramic.

More Kitchen Buys You'll Love

Next Up

The Best Expensive-Looking Glassware Under $50 on Amazon

Shop our top picks for high-quality, beautiful glassware in unique shapes and styles — all for under $50 on Amazon.

How the Zwilling Food Vacuum Sealer Helped Me Take Fewer Trips to the Grocery Store

Save money, reduce food waste, take fewer trips to the grocery store and eat healthier with this vacuum sealer set that will help your food last five times longer.

Why Hamilton Beach's 2-in-1 Countertop Oven & Toaster Is One of My Tried-and-True Kitchen Staples

If dual functionality, space-saving design and ease of use are your top criteria for countertop appliances, then take a look at this combination mini oven and toaster.

Transform Your Instant Pot Into an Air Fryer With This Space-Saving Lid We Tried and Loved

For those who want to try air frying their favorite foods but have run out of room to store yet another kitchen appliance, Instant Pot's Air Fryer Lid is the perfect solution.

26 Clever Kitchen Tools That Will Help You Breeze Through Food Prep

Simplify the meal-prep process with our list of smart and affordable kitchen gadgets.

The Best Places to Buy Kitchen Cabinets Online

Cook up the kitchen of your dreams with these failproof cabinet retailers.

10 Best Knives for Home Chefs

Whether you're paring apples or carving your holiday roast, you need a kitchen knife that's a cut above the rest.

The Best (and Last) Kitchen Trash Can You'll Ever Buy

Taking out the trash is a chore no more. Wave goodbye to germs and hello to a touch-free trash bin that will change your kitchen game for good.

The Best Air Fryers of 2022 for Every Budget and Household

Find out everything you need to know about air fryers and where to buy the best model for you and your household.

13 Best Countertop Compost Bins for Your Kitchen

Composting food scraps in your home is a great way to cut down on landfill waste and upcycle peels, cores and seeds into nutrients for your garden. These countertop compost bins keep it all smell-free and mess-free.

Go Shopping

Refresh your home with stylish products handpicked by HGTV editors.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.