DIY Valentine's Day Conversation Heart Keychain

The iconic candy now comes in keychain form. Make this adorable accessory for your BFF, special someone or yourself.

Woman Holding Purse With Heart Keychain That Says "Be Mine"

Be Mine Conversation Heart Keychain

This adorable conversation heart-inspired keychain is made with clay from the craft store. It makes the perfect gift for Valentine’s Day. Add a tassel or pom-pom for an extra embellishment.

Photo by: Cassidy Garcia

Cassidy Garcia

Follow Deanne on:

Conversation hearts are hands down the nastiest tasting candy ever invented, but they also have a great aesthetic. It just wouldn’t be Valentine’s Day without those retro, pastel hearts. There are so many conversation heart-inspired decorations and gifts to buy for February 14, but, if you’re on a budget, you can make these easy keychains on the cheap with just a few supplies from the craft store. Watch editor Gabriela Hardan whip up these cute accessories in a snap and read on for the full how-to.

Woman Holding Clay Heart That Says Call Me

DIY Conversation Heart Keychain

HGTV editor Gabriela Hardan has the cutest how-to for DIY conversation heart keychains.

Photo by: Cassidy Garcia

Cassidy Garcia

Materials Needed:

  • clay (pastel colors)
  • rolling pin
  • parchment paper
  • cookie cutter
  • letter stamps
  • paint brush
  • paint
  • eye hook
  • metal ring
  • lobster clasp
  • tassel (optional)

Shape the Clay

Preheat your oven according to the clay package’s instructions. Roll a piece of clay into a ball to soften. Place the ball of clay on parchment paper to prevent sticking and press down on the ball with the palm of your hand to flatten the clay. Using a rolling pin, roll over the top of the flattened clay to smooth out the surface. Keep the clay thick to resemble the actual thickness of a conversation candy heart. Using a heart-shaped cookie cutter, cut the clay. Remove excess dough. Insert a small eye hook screw into the top left corner of the heart to later connect a keychain.

Decorate + Bake

Use rubber letter stamps to lightly imprint a phrase on the heart. Common conversational heart phrases include XOXO, BE MINE, LOVE YOU or CALL ME. Repeat the steps above for additional hearts. Bake according to your clay package’s instruction, but, as a general rule, bake 15 minutes per quarter inch of thickness. The hearts Gabriela made are about a half-inch thick and cured for about 30 minutes. Remove from the oven and let cool completely. Using a fine, detailed paintbrush, go over the imprinted letters with red paint. Let dry. Attach a lobster clasp and metal ring to the eye hook. Add a tassel or pom-pom for extra embellishment.

Tales From a Non-Crafter
Loading Video...

Valentine's Day Crafts + DIY Gifts

Valentine’s Day Shrinky Dinks 3 Ways

Skip the chocolates and roses and try this retro craft by The Crafty Lumberjacks.

Next Up

Giant M&M Cookies Recipe

Try this nostalgic cookie recipe that mixes M&M's into classic sugar cookie dough for a treat that's soft, chewy and delicious as ever.

Chocolate Soup (for Two) Recipe

Chocolate soup is a fun and unexpected way to end Valentine's Day dinner. Silky and indulgent, this recipe generously serves two. Use bittersweet chocolate chips or your favorite brand of chocolate bar.

Cupid's Crispie Treats Recipe

These little crispie treats are spiced up just a bit with the addition of cinnamon imperials. We gave ours a sweet twist by inserting arrows straight from Cupid's bow.

Chocolate-Covered Strawberry Cookie Truffles Recipe

Original chocolate truffles have graced birthday, potluck and holiday parties for years. These truffles provide a little twist on the classic recipe and combine everyone's favorite duo: chocolate and strawberries.

Red Wine Lollipop Recipe

Red wine is an unexpected ingredient to incorporate into desserts. These lollipops were created with Port wine, but you can try your favorite variety of red.

Make Homemade Play Dough Valentines

Ditch the store-bought valentines and try something new this year. The kids will love helping you make homemade, heart-shaped play dough to hand out to friends and classmates.

Kids' Craft: Biggest Fan Valentine

Nothing sends a heartwarming message to loved ones like a handmade valentine. This year, show the object of your affection that you're their "biggest fan" with this clever, easy-to-make card.

Craft Throwback: Valentine’s Day Shrinky Dinks 3 Ways

Skip the chocolates and roses and make cute handmade gifts with this retro craft by The Crafty Lumberjacks.

Kids' Craft: Handmade Turtle Valentine

Let that special someone know exactly how you feel with this sweet turtle card that reads, "You really bring me out of my shell."

How to Make a Valentine's Day Phrase Pillow

Show your significant other just how much you care with a colorful, one-of-a-kind pillow that can be showcased all year round.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

About HGTV

HGTV’s expert editors and writers share home decorating, garden and home improvement ideas, inspiration and advice based on our brand’s 30+ years of expertise and experience. We also give you the latest updates on HGTV shows and stars, cleaning tips and shopping recommendations. Learn more about us and our editorial standards.