Make Valentine's Day Conversation Heart Cookies

This Valentine's Day, swap chalky conversation heart candies for colorful (and delicious!) vanilla sandwich cookies stamped with custom messages.


By: Liz Gray

Materials Needed:

  • sugar cookie dough (recipe follows)
  • 4 colors gel paste food coloring
  • plastic wrap
  • powdered sugar
  • parchment paper
  • rolling pin
  • 1", 1-1/2" and 2"heart-shaped cookie cutters
  • black food-safe decorating pen
  • custom stamp-setting kit
  • vanilla cream filling (recipe follows)
  • offset spatula
  • glassine bags (optional)
  • red baker's twine (optional)
  • heart-shaped stickers (optional)

Create Colored Sugar Cookie Dough

Mix up the sugar cookie dough and add gel paste food coloring. The following recipe will yield approximately 4 dozen total sandwich cookies with a mix of 1-inch, 1 1/2-inch and 2-inch sizes.

Alton Brown's Sugar Cookies
Recipe courtesy Food Network

3 cups all-purpose flour
3/4 teaspoon baking powder
1/4 teaspoon salt
1 cup unsalted butter, softened
1 cup sugar
1 egg, beaten
1 tablespoon milk

Sift together flour, baking powder, and salt. Set aside. Place butter and sugar in large bowl of electric stand mixer and beat until light in color. Add egg and milk and beat to combine. Put mixer on low speed, gradually add flour, and beat until mixture pulls away from the side of the bowl.

Tip: No time to make your own? Substitute a 30-ounce roll of room-temperature prepared cookie dough.

Divide the room-temperature dough into four sections. Add a different gel paste hue to each section: 5 drops per section of dough will create the vibrant hues seen here; 3 drops per section will create lighter, pastel hues. Knead in each color until fully combined, washing hands thoroughly after each addition. Wrap each dough round in plastic wrap and refrigerate for 2 hours, or overnight.

Roll, Cut and Bake Cookies

Preheat oven to 375 degrees F. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper.

Sprinkle rolling surface with powdered sugar. Remove one round from the refrigerator. Rub the rolling pin with a thin coating of powdered sugar, then roll the dough to 1/4-inch thick, moving frequently to make sure it isn't sticking.

Cut out even numbers of the 1-inch, 1-1/2 inch and 2-inch hearts. Place on baking sheet. Reroll cookie dough and repeat until dough is gone. Bake until just barely golden around the edges; about 7 minutes for 1-inch cookies, 9 minutes for 1-1/2 inch cookies and 11 minutes for 2-inch cookies. Cool on a wire rack. Repeat with remaining colored dough rounds.

Pair up the matching cookies, choosing the most attractive pieces to be the top layer of each sandwich.

Make Cream Filling

While the cookies cool, make the cream filling.

Vanilla Cream Filling

1 stick unsalted butter, at room temperature
3 cups confectioners' sugar
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1 tablespoon plus one teaspoon vanilla extract
Water, as needed

In a stand mixer with the paddle attachment, cream the butter until light and fluffy, about three minutes. Reduce speed and gradually add sugars. Add vanilla and beat until just combined.

Tip: The filling should be spreadable but not runny. If it's too thick, add water a teaspoon at a time until it reaches the desired consistency.



Stamp and Assemble Cookies

Using a customizable stamp kit and the included tweezers, select the message you want to stamp on your cookie. Use conversation hearts for inspiration, or create your own custom sayings. Using a food-safe black decorating pen (available at baking supply stores), color the letters on the stamp. Press down gently to trasfer the message to the top of each cookie. Reapply ink to stamp additional cookies, changing message as desired.

Tip: Test the stamp on a piece of paper before trying a cookie to make sure the letters are properly spaced.

Using an offset spatula, spread a thin layer of vanilla cream filling onto the bottom cookie. Press the top and bottom cookies together gently to create the finished sandwich. Repeat until cookies are gone.

Package and Enjoy

Store the finished cookies in an airtight container for up to one week. To give as an individually-wrapped Valentine's Day gift, package cookies in glassine bags tied with striped baker's twine and sealed with a heart-shaped sticker.

Next Up

Giant M&M Cookies Recipe

Try this nostalgic cookie recipe that mixes M&M's into classic sugar cookie dough for a treat that's soft, chewy and delicious as ever.

Cupid's Crispie Treats Recipe

These little crispie treats are spiced up just a bit with the addition of cinnamon imperials. We gave ours a sweet twist by inserting arrows straight from Cupid's bow.

Eclairs With White Chocolate and Strawberries Recipe

Take a trip to France this Valentine's Day by making your sweetheart homemade eclairs covered in white chocolate and topped with strawberries.

Pink Raspberry Macaron Recipe

Bring Parisian flair to your Valentine's Day party with pink raspberry macarons.

Chocolate Soup (for Two) Recipe

Chocolate soup is a fun and unexpected way to end Valentine's Day dinner. Silky and indulgent, this recipe generously serves two. Use bittersweet chocolate chips or your favorite brand of chocolate bar.

Neapolitan Bonbon Cupcakes Recipe

Fancy chocolates make a festive topping for these Neapolitan cupcakes. For an extra-special gift, use your sweetheart's favorite variety to finish off these treats.

Heritage Red Velvet Cake Recipe

This cake gets its heart shape from a hand-drawn template and serrated knife — no specialty pans required here.

Homemade Valentine's Day Mints Recipe

These homemade candy hearts will surely impress your valentine. You can even add their favorite color or flavoring for an extra-special touch.

Chocolate-Covered Strawberry Cookie Truffles Recipe

Original chocolate truffles have graced birthday, potluck and holiday parties for years. These truffles provide a little twist on the classic recipe and combine everyone's favorite duo: chocolate and strawberries.

Perfect Cut-Out Sugar Cookies Recipe

Bake the perfect batch of sugar cookies to decorate for your loved ones this Valentine's Day.

Go Shopping

Refresh your home with stylish products handpicked by HGTV editors.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.

Related Pages