Halloween Makeup Tutorial: Pirate

This weathered Caribbean pirate look is easy to achieve in less than 30 minutes using basic makeup and a few specialty items from the costume shop.
Man in pirate Halloween costume

Halloween Makeup Tutorial: Pirate

This weathered Caribbean pirate look is easy to achieve in less than 30 minutes using basic makeup and a few specialty items from the costume shop.

This weathered Caribbean pirate look is easy to achieve in less than 30 minutes using basic makeup and a few specialty items from the costume shop.
By: Colleen Herman

Materials Needed:

  • foundation (several shades darker than skin tone)
  • eye shadow: powder and cream in dark brown, gray or black
  • black eyeliners
  • translucent powder and puff
  • makeup or craft brushes
  • makeup applicators
  • stipple sponge
  • black and gold tooth polish (available at a costume shop)

Apply Foundation

Begin by applying foundation to the face and neck that's several shades darker than the natural skin tone (Image 1).

Woman applying Halloween pirate makeup to man

Apply Foundation

Begin by applying foundation to the face and neck that's several shades darker than the natural skin tone.

Intensify Eyebrows

Use a dark eyebrow pencil to fill in the brows and make them thicker than normal. Use a small craft brush with brown or black eye shadow to create the illusion of extra hairs by pulling the color up in tiny lines (Image 1). Make the brows large and unkempt looking by making the hair lines different thicknesses and uneven.

Woman applying Halloween pirate makeup to man

Intensify Eyebrows

Use a dark eyebrow pencil to fill in the brows and make them thicker than normal. Use a small craft brush with brown or black eye shadow to create the illusion of extra hairs by pulling the color up in tiny lines. Make the brows large and unkempt looking by making the hair lines different thicknesses and uneven

Create Tired Eyes

Using an eye shadow brush, apply brown eye shadow to the crease of the eyes, blending it down to the lower lid (Image 1). The goal is to make the eyes look tired. Use black eyeliner to line the bottom and top of the eyelids. Then, use a small craft brush to blend this line out with black eye shadow (Image 2).

Weather the Skin

Using a craft brush and brown eye shadow, create contours under the cheek bones, blending down and out for a hollow look (Image 1). Add wrinkles from the long days in the sun by using the brush to make crease lines between the eyebrows, in the nasal folds and a few on the forehead (Image 2). Now, add shading under the bottom lip (Image 3). Then, add gray shadow to parts of the lines – the more color, the more realistic looking. Pucker the lips and add some dark shadow to the lines that exist naturally (Image 4).

Add a Beard

To give your pirate beard growth, dip the stipple sponge into black and brown cream makeup, then lightly dot onto the face. Add age spots and an uneven skin tone using the stipple sponge, dabbing gray and brown eye shadow onto the forehead and cheeks (Image 1). Finally, pat on translucent powder with a puff and brush off excess to set the makeup (Image 2).

Complete the Look

Since pirates don't brush their teeth, use black and gold tooth polish (available from a costume shop) to make some teeth disappear and others sparkle (Image 1). Add a bandana or hat, long wig, lots of jewelry and pirate's clothing to complete the look (Image 2).

Next Up

Halloween Pet Costume: Court Jester

This Halloween honor your pet's inner clown with an easy-to-sew felt jester costume. Our free printable templates make stitching up this playful costume a snap.

25 Best Pop Culture Halloween Costume Ideas for 2023

Make an entrance (and earn a lot of laughs) with these Halloween costumes inspired by Barbie, The Little Mermaid, Ted Lasso, Taylor Swift, boy bands, TikTok trends and other iconic 2023 moments.

The 56 Best Halloween Costumes You Can Order Online

Check out these cute costume ideas for the whole family.

40+ Last-Minute Halloween Costumes You Can Order Online

Are the holidays sneaking up on you? We've got you covered for the first one to hit the scene — Halloween — with costumes you can get delivered to your home in a matter of days.

Paper Bag Halloween Costumes 3 Ways

Save time and money this year by crafting these adorable paper bag Halloween costumes.

5 Easy Halloween Costumes You Can Make With a T-Shirt

We're taking the plain white tee to a whole new level.

10 Fun Ways to Treat Your Favorite Pup This Halloween

Halloween isn't just for humans! Show your four-legged best friend some love with these festive dog treats, toys, accessories and costumes.

How to Make a Classic Tulle Tutu

This pretty DIY skirt looks adorable as a flower girl dress, a Halloween costume, for ballerinas-in-training or just for the fun of it. Almost no sewing is involved to create this classic tulle tutu, making it a great project for beginner-level crafters.

How to Make Halloween Tombstones From Upcycled Styrofoam

Upgrade your outdoor Halloween decor and create a creepy graveyard scene with this easy-to-make Styrofoam tombstone complete with custom epitaphs.

How to Make a Life-Size Halloween Ghost

Create a life-size ghost for Halloween using cheesecloth and other inexpensive items. Hang it from a tree or place it on your front porch so passersby will shake in their boots.

More from:

Halloween Ideas

What's New in Handmade

On TV

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.