The 7 Best Mattress Toppers of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

If your mattress isn't cutting it but you're not ready to upgrade, consider a comfortable mattress topper. From memory foam to feather, these toppers will make you feel like you're sleeping in a 5-star hotel.

Keep in mind: Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money from these affiliate links.
Updated on March 09, 2023

Our Top Mattress Topper Picks

We all know we spend about a third of our lives sleeping, so anything that can make our beds more comfortable and make sleep come easier is a worthwhile investment in our book. A high-quality mattress is one of the most important investments you can make, of course, but sometimes upgrading a mattress isn't always feasible or necessary. Maybe you inherited a hand-me-down mattress from family or simply bought the first one you saw at a big-box store a few years ago and now regret it, but you can't stomach spending another $700+ on a new mattress yet. If your bed is too firm and you’re looking to add more cushion to soften it up, a mattress topper is a perfect alternative to buying a new mattress. If you want to extend the life of your mattress, a mattress topper is also a great way to keep it from sagging over time. Plus, mattress toppers can also help relieve pain from pressure points. If your mattress is drooping or is very old, though, a mattress topper isn’t a long-term solution — you probably need a new mattress.

What's the Difference Between Mattress Toppers, Pads and Protectors?

Mattress toppers primarily address comfort and are usually at least an inch or two tall. Toppers simply rest on top of the mattress, and while some may have corner straps for extra security, most toppers are held in place by your fitted sheet. Mattress toppers are also the most expensive of the three products. Mattress pads usually only provide a very thin layer of extra padding and are less expensive than toppers. While mattress pads serve as a barrier from spills reaching your mattress, they're not necessarily waterproof and don't offer complete protection against bedbugs. Pads usually fit on your mattress like a fitted sheet. Mattress protectors don't provide any added comfort either and are also less expensive than toppers. As the name suggests though, the primary purpose of a mattress protector is to protect your mattress from larger accidents, spills, dust and bedbugs. Toppers and pads can extend the life of your mattress to some degree since they still provide a physical barrier, but a protector is the best option, either on its own or in combination with a topper, to use if you're specifically looking to keep your mattress safe from potential spills or damage.

How to Choose a Mattress Topper

Like mattresses, mattress toppers come in a variety of firmnesses, thicknesses and materials. The most popular types of toppers include memory foam, latex, pillow-top (made from either feather fill or down alternative fill) and hybrid toppers made of multiple materials.

Memory Foam Mattress Toppers

Memory foam is the most popular type of topper because you can find one at a range of price points and the material provides support, comfort and pressure relief to any type of mattress.

Latex Mattress Toppers

Latex is a natural foam made from rubber trees that provides a similar feel to memory foam, which is made from petroleum, and it is durable, but often more expensive.

Pillow-Top Mattress Toppers

Pillow-top mattress toppers offer a softer, cloud-like comfort and usually feature baffle-box stitching filled with either luxurious down feathers or a down-alternative fiberfill.

Hybrid Mattress Toppers

Hybrid toppers often combine memory foam or latex with a thinner pillow-top layer if you're looking for features of both.

Before purchasing a topper, make sure any fitted mattress pads, protectors and sheets you plan to use will fit over your mattress and the mattress topper you're considering. You'll need to consider the extra inches a mattress topper adds anytime you purchase new sheets, so if your mattress is on the taller side, you may want to opt for a 2-3-inch topper instead of a 4-inch one. We tried some of the top-rated options on the market, and these are our top picks for mattress toppers.

From $299

Memory foam is the most popular type of topper because it’s soft and comfortable and can reduce motion transfer, which is great if your partner moves around a lot at night and you're a light sleeper, for example. Memory foam also helps reduce pain in the pressure points. If you're after that moldable, soft-but-firm feel of memory foam, this topper from Tempur-pedic is a solid choice. Allow for a few days after unboxing to air out the topper and let it expand fully before placing on the bed. A minor new-product smell that our tester noticed after opening dissipated after a day or so and the topper fully expanded in less than 48 hours. At three inches, the height of this topper is ideal and not too high to make getting a fitted sheet over it a concern. The memory foam provides just the right amount of softness but also doesn't make you feel like you're sinking. Note that this product can't be returned, but it does come with a 10-year limited warranty.

Our Editor Says: "I have mattress regret after buying one of the first options I saw at a big-box store several years back, but I'm not ready to splurge on a new king-size mattress I hope to upgrade to one day. I LOVE how this memory foam topper added a cloud-like softness to my traditional innerspring mattress and made it so much more comfortable."

From $299 | Amazon
From $76.70

If you're on a tighter budget but still want the luxurious comfort of memory foam, this pick from Best Price is a great deal. Constructed of a layer of high-density foam and a layer of memory foam infused with green tea, this topper comes in both three- and four-inch heights. Our tester noted that this topper had a subtle smell for the first few days and did take a little longer to expand to its full size than our best memory foam pick. The 4-inch topper was a little too high for our tester, so we recommend going with the 3-inch option if available. We also love that this topper comes in seven sizes, ranging from twin to California king.

Our Editor Says: "This mattress topper completely molded to my body and softened up my firmer innerspring mattress, and, at just over $100, it's a great deal for anyone who wants to upgrade their bed without replacing their entire mattress."

Buy It
From $299

If you sleep on your side or experience hip, back or neck pain, this mattress topper from Nolah, constructed of their proprietary cooling AirFoam, is a great option to add extra cushion and pressure relief. It comes in two firmness levels: plush and luxury firm. Our tester, who usually sleeps on her side or stomach, tried the plush version and felt supported in both positions and noted the foam perfectly molded to her curves. This foam topper features an organic cotton quilted cover and corner straps to prevent the topper from sliding around, a feature our tester really appreciated after having other toppers shift around when changing sheets in the past. She also noted that this topper does have a cooling effect, so if you're a hot sleeper, this is a great option. This mattress comes in six sizes and measures two inches tall, meaning most fitted sheets shouldn't have a problem fitting over the topper and mattress.

Our Editor Says: "The quilted cotton cover, the coziness of the foam cushion and the stability of the straps holding it in place really makes it feel like you are sleeping on a brand new mattress, and that isn’t something I have experienced with any of the other mattress toppers I've tried before."

Buy It
From $49.90

Dorm mattresses and mattresses in furnished college apartments are notoriously uncomfortable. They're typically innerspring mattresses on the firmer side. A mattress topper can be super helpful to make them more comfortable, but you probably don't want to spend more than $100 on a bed you'll only use for a year or two. To add a bit of softness and extra cushion without breaking the bank, this pillow-top mattress topper from Amazon is a great value. It features a cotton shell and down alternative fiberfill, so it adds softness without adding much height at all. This topper fits on the mattress like a fitted sheet and the whole thing is machine washable, which is a must when your dorm bed is often where you study, snack and spend a lot of your time. It also comes in eight sizes, including twin XL.

Our Editor Says: "This mattress topper is super comfortable and made my mattress much softer. I slept better and woke up feeling more refreshed."

Buy It
From $399

For hot sleepers and people with older mattresses that can sometimes retain more heat than newer mattresses, a cooling topper can ensure you don't wake up sweating throughout the night. Like the TEMPUR-Topper Supreme, this TEMPUR-Adapt + Cooling Topper is the ideal height of three inches and comes with a cool-to-the-touch, allergen-resistant, removable cover that's machine washable. Our tester did find the cover a little tricky to get on but enjoyed sleeping on a softer surface compared to her firm memory foam mattress. However, this topper is probably not the best choice for sleepers who prefer firm mattresses. Note that this product can't be returned, but it does come with a 10-year limited warranty.

Our Editor Says: "I like that this topper isn’t too thick! It gave a little height to the bed without making it too tall. I also didn’t feel my husband move at all, which might be a plus for some people."

From $399 | Amazon
From $209

If you want your bed to feel like a luxury hotel bed, a feather-filled topper is probably what you're looking for. Designed with baffle-box stitching to limit shifting and available in three sizes, this 3-inch Pottery Barn featherbed is made of 100-percent, 230-thread-count cotton and filled with hypoallergenic small, white feathers. With some luxury featherbeds pushing up into the $400 plus range, this Pottery Barn topper is plenty cozy and luxurious for a reasonable price.

Our Editor Says: "The topper was the most comfortable and plush featherbed mattress topper of the three I tried, and it stayed plush and fluffy even without regular fluffing."

Buy It

Achieve Luxury Hotel Comfort at Home With a Top-Rated Featherbed Mattress Topper

Want the cozy bedtime experience of sleeping on a cloud? Feel like you are staying at a fancy hotel and upgrade the comfort level of your mattress with a plush, downy featherbed mattress cover. Read on for our top picks.

From $199

A great option for anyone who wants that featherbed-like softness but is allergic to down or prefers vegan products, this down-alternative, cloud-like mattress topper earned a glowing review from our tester. Parachute's topper is made of 100-percent hypoallergenic microfill and features a 100-percent sateen cotton shell and a baffle-box construction to prevent shifting. With a gusset height measuring about three inches, this topper is an ideal height, and our tester said that even though it doesn't come with straps like some toppers, her fitted sheet held this one in place nicely. It actually made her king sheets fit better on her 11-inch memory foam mattress. Available in six sizes, this topper also comes with a three-year warranty.

Our Editor Says: "I love how this topper has completely transformed my bed. I thought my bed was comfortable before, but adding this topper gives it next-level luxury. I used to love sinking into my sofa and relaxing after dinner, but I’m all about heading to the bedroom to watch TV or read. It’s definitely my favorite spot in the house now."

Buy It

How We Tested

The team of HGTV editors, consisting of side, back and stomach sleepers, has tested more than 12 mattresses toppers on a variety of mattresses, from innerspring to memory foam, to make our selections. We unboxed the mattress toppers and noted any initial smells that needed to dissipate or expansion time necessary. We slept on the majority of the mattress toppers we tested for more than a year, with the exception of the most recent products we've added to our list of contenders. We took note of how well the toppers fit our mattresses, how easy our fitted sheets go over both the mattress and topper and whether or not the toppers stay in place. We also observed any changes to our (and our sleeping partner's) temperature and comfort while sleeping on the mattress toppers to make our selections.

More Bedding Essentials for Better Sleep

Next Up

The Best Sheets of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

Find the perfect sheets for your sleep style from our editor-approved selection of top-rated bedding.

The Best Duvets of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

From luxurious down to hypoallergenic down-alternative duvets, top your bed with one of these cloud-like comforters.

The Best Duvet Covers of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

Whether you're a hot sleeper or are looking for organic bedding, add one of our top-rated, tested duvet cover recommendations to your bed.

The Best Silk Sheets of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

If you're looking to upgrade your bedding, shop our favorite luxurious silk sheets, from budget to splurge-worthy picks. Plus, get recommendations for the best silk alternative sheets like bamboo and eucalyptus.

The Best Cotton Sheets of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

Cotton is a go-to material for everyday sheets for all kinds of sleepers for good reason. After testing dozens of brands, we've rounded up the best of the best cotton sheets, from budget to luxury and sateen to percale.

The Best Cooling Weighted Blankets in 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

Want to feel calmer and sleep deeper without getting overheated? Check out our favorite cooling weighted blankets that are best for hot sleepers and hot summers.

The Best Cooling Sheets of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

No more waking up drenched in sweat — beat the heat with one of these lightweight, breathable sheet sets, tested and approved by HGTV editors.

The Best Bamboo Sheets of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

From high-end to budget-friendly, these are our editors' top picks for the best bamboo sheets.

The Best Sleep Masks of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

Improve your sleep quality with an eye mask that will comfortably block out the light, whether you're in bed, on the road or in the air.

The Best Pillows of 2023, Tested by HGTV Editors

Drift off into dreamland with one of these editor-tested and approved pillows.