Get a Bargain on a Stigmatized Property

You can find a bargain in just about every neighborhood these days, but if you’re looking for a deal with a price that’s been “slashed,” try searching for the home where the “slasher” lived.
By: John Morell

Stigmatized properties are those that were the scene of a gruesome crime or event, the home of a notorious criminal, or both. In highly publicized cases, like that of O.J. Simpson, the house is often purchased, razed, and a new home is built to try and shed the past. In others, such as the Modesto, California home of Lacy and Scott Peterson, market conditions have prevented a teardown.

A 2000 study from Wright State University found that on average, stigmas caused a sale price to drop just three percent. But stigmatized homes were also on the market 45 percent longer than comparable houses. “Over time, memories fade and the stigma usually fades away,” says Randall Bell of Bell, Anderson & Sanders LLC, a Laguna Beach, Calif. real estate consultancy. “But can you afford to wait it out is the question.”

“Buying a house is a business transaction, but it’s also emotional,” says Frank Harrison, a property appraiser based in Woodstock, IL. “You may find a home you like but then you’re told someone died there. If an old man dies in his sleep, you might not think that’s so awful. But if it was a child, or a suicide, that might cause you to reconsider.”

In gentrified urban areas, stigmas can take on other forms. “In cities going through redevelopment you might have a block of beautifully re-done homes and a local gang decides to tag the area as its territory,” says Harrison. “Until law enforcement gets involved and the graffiti stops for good, values in the entire neighborhood suffer.”

Another issue occurs when a home with a recent past as the area’s “crack joint” or meth factory is remodeled and put on the market. “It’s usually the last one on the street to sell,” says Harrison. “It may be beautiful now, but people worry about the drugs and chemicals used there and they also wonder, what if an old customer shows up at their door one night looking for merchandise?”

Shopping for stigmatized properties

Most states have laws requiring Realtors and/or owners to disclose stigmas to potential buyers, but the rules can be vague. “There are quite a few intricacies and exclusions,” says Bell. “If something is at all an issue for you, ask them directly.”

Interested in buying a stigmatized home? You’re not alone. “They’re bargains if you can accept their past,” says Harrison. One of his more memorable appraisals was for a couple who purchased a Chicago home that was the site of a brutal murder. It was bought by a soldier and his Japanese wife who were happy to get a nicer home than they thought they could buy and who didn’t mind the home’s lurid history. “The wife brought her father to live with them from Japan and they felt very comfortable putting him in the room where the crime occurred.”

Next Up

Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Home in Foreclosure

Purchasing a foreclosed home can mean getting a bargain, but there are potential pitfalls too.

For Sale By Owner (FSBO): How to Sell Your Home by Yourself

Are you considering selling your home without a real estate agent? Follow these tips to make the process as smooth as possible.

Short Sale Rules: What You Need to Know

A short sale occurs when a property is sold for less than what is owed on the mortgage with the lender's approval. Learn the advantages and disadvantages of this type of transaction for the seller and the buyer.

What Foreclosure Means and How to Stop It From Happening

Learn about the various steps in the foreclosure process and ways you can avoid losing your home.

The Skinny on the Short Sale

How to get a short sale when you're facing foreclosure on a house.

Did I Accept a Bad Offer on My Home?

Worried you accepted a bad offer for your home? Let real estate expert soothe your fears.

How to Quickly Sell Your Home When Threatened With Foreclosure

Get tips and advice on how to sell your home fast.

How to Deal With Your Lender When Facing Foreclosure

In the foreclosure world, "workout" has nothing to do with the elliptical trainer. It's about cutting a deal with your lender to stop the foreclosure process.

Sellers: What to Do When You Can't Find a Home Before Yours Sells

If you sold your house before you've found new digs, don't worry: You have options.

Pros + Cons of Rent-to-Own Agreements for Buyers and Sellers

For both the seller and homebuyer, renting to own a house can be a dream come true — or a nightmare. Find out if this type of real estate transaction is right for you.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.