A Christmasholic Gets Quizzed on the Amount of Ornaments in His Collection and Gets Every Answer Wrong

He was just being modest!

Homeowners Dominick Marangi and Matt Tumminello  pose in the basement storage space featuring various Christmas decorations, as seen on Holiday Hoarders, Season 1.

Dominick (left) started collecting Christmas decor when he was a child. Matt discovered his husband's "Christmas obsession" the first time he visited Dominick's parents' house.

Photo by: Anders Krusberg

Anders Krusberg

Dominick (left) started collecting Christmas decor when he was a child. Matt discovered his husband's "Christmas obsession" the first time he visited Dominick's parents' house.

Follow Jessica on:

HGTV's Hoarding for the Holidays follows true fanatics. The kind that make any quirky aunt or uncle's tchotchkes look tame. From blow-mold collections that reach upward of 1,000 figurines to building an operating backyard Ferris wheel for holiday light displays, these holiday decorators mean business. But since Christmas does only come but once a year, these dedicated enthusiasts have a little storage problem. That is, the storage space needed to house all those wreaths, ornaments and Christmas trees requires everything from storage units to literal acres of land.

That's where Dominick and his husband, Matt, come in. Their 2,500-square-foot basement is filled with larger-than-life nutcrackers, miles of Christmas lights and too many ornaments to count.

Homeowners Dominick Marangi and Matt Tumminello’s basement storage space featuring various Christmas decorations, as seen on Holiday Hoarders, Season 1.

Dominick says if you don't like something, then you don't have to count it as part of your collection. Cool!

Photo by: Anders Krusberg

Anders Krusberg

Dominick says if you don't like something, then you don't have to count it as part of your collection. Cool!

Or is it? With the cameras rolling, Matt quizzed Dominick to see if he actually knows just how much Christmas decor he really has. The results? He was off by … a lot.

But who hasn't messed up a quiz before in their life? The HGTV audience rallied behind Dominick and his decorations. One commenter lamented, "It's hard to see other people living your dreams." Others agreed that if it's holiday decor, it doesn't count, cue a chorus of comments saying, "I don't see a problem here."

Homeowners Dominick Marangi and Matt Tumminello pose in the warehouse, as seen on Holiday Hoarders, Season 1.

Dominick (left) has a warehouse he used to run sales out of for his antique business, but now it houses some of his larger decorations and a partial collection of his 121 Christmas trees.

Photo by: Anders Krusberg

Anders Krusberg

Dominick (left) has a warehouse he used to run sales out of for his antique business, but now it houses some of his larger decorations and a partial collection of his 121 Christmas trees.

You can trust that it's totally worth the trouble. Dominick, who also collects and sells antiques in his Provincetown, Massachusetts, shop, has a stellar eye for design, and his regal holiday displays belong on the cover of a magazine.

Homeowners Dominick Marangi and Matt Tumminello’s dining room, as seen on Holiday Hoarders, Season 1.

Worth it.

Photo by: Anders Krusberg

Anders Krusberg

Worth it.

Dominick spends the months leading up to Christmas executing his decorating vision for the year, working up until his and Matt's annual Christmas party. The party started out as a small gathering and morphed into a 200-person event.

Homeowners Dominick Marangi and Matt Tumminello’s living room featuring a large Christmas tree, as seen on Holiday Hoarders, Season 1.

This vintage-style tree holds more than 10,000 lights and 2,000 ornaments. Matt says he tries not to touch it.

Photo by: Anders Krusberg

Anders Krusberg

This vintage-style tree holds more than 10,000 lights and 2,000 ornaments. Matt says he tries not to touch it.

But Dominick says poring over the year's design is like "therapy" to him, and it brings him a lot of joy.

Homeowners Dominick Marangi and Matt Tumminello’s bathroom as seen on Holiday Hoarders, Season 1.

Some HGTV Instagram followers theorized Matt quizzed Dominick in the bathroom because it was the only space not filled with Christmas decorations, but we'd never leave this bathroom, either.

Photo by: Anders Krusberg

Anders Krusberg

Some HGTV Instagram followers theorized Matt quizzed Dominick in the bathroom because it was the only space not filled with Christmas decorations, but we'd never leave this bathroom, either.

And that joy is evident from the 4 million views on HGTV's post. If Dominick ever wants to take his holiday decorating skills on the road, he's got thousands of new fans!

Homeowners Matt Tumminello and Dominick Marangi pose with the peacock decor, as seen on Holiday Hoarders, Season 1.

"It's not that bizarre, it's wonderful," Dominick (left) says of a pair of decorative peacocks he named Mama-race and Liberace when he unearthed them in the warehouse.

Photo by: Anders Krusberg

Anders Krusberg

"It's not that bizarre, it's wonderful," Dominick (left) says of a pair of decorative peacocks he named Mama-race and Liberace when he unearthed them in the warehouse.

Next Up

Get Ready for Shark Week With These Fierce Finds

Show your love for those magnificent underwater predators just in time for the best week of the year. Tune into Shark Week, starting July 26th, on Discovery.

The Coziest Fall Home Finds You Can Get on Amazon

It's never too soon to start planning for fall — and here are our picks for the coziest fall decor and accessories on Amazon for your home.

Nate Berkus Added New Colorways to His Collection With Rugs USA, and We Couldn’t Be More Excited

The former HGTV star is building on his original designs with the rug company, particularly with a warm neutral color palette.

13 Christmas Ornament Sets for Every Holiday Style

Trim your holiday tree in style with personality-packed baubles.

84 Best Father's Day Gifts You Can Get on Amazon

Show the dads in your life the love they deserve with a thoughtful gift, no matter their interests or your budget.

MacKenzie-Childs Has a New Outdoor Dining Collection, and We Want Every Single Item

The melamine and acrylic designs are durable — and adorable.

Get to Know the Hosts of 'Maine Cabin Masters: All Inn'

Chase and Sarah Morrill are renovating a 12-acre bed-and-breakfast property on Maine Cabin Masters: All Inn. Learn more about the duo with HGTV.

Get to Know Leslie Jones, Host of 'Roast My Rental'

Leslie Jones is roasting rentals across America in HGTV's all-new series Roast My Rental. Learn more about the comedian and actress with HGTV.

Get to Know the Savvy Hosts of HGTV's 'Farmhouse Facelift'

Carolyn Wilbrink and Billy Pearson have a knack for updating rundown farmhouses.

Get Glowing With These Indoor Lighting Buys That Look Designer Without the Price Tag

Add some fresh new light fixtures to your evening lamp o'clock routine.

On TV

What's New in Shows

Luxury Home Giveaways

HGTV Smart Home

A sophisticated, sporty home in San Antonio, Texas

HGTV Dream Home

A lakeside retreat on Lake Wylie in Charlotte, North Carolina

Follow HGTV on Social

Keep up with HGTV designers and hosts.

About HGTV

HGTV’s expert editors and writers share home decorating, garden and home improvement ideas, inspiration and advice based on our brand’s 30+ years of expertise and experience. We also give you the latest updates on HGTV shows and stars, cleaning tips and shopping recommendations. Learn more about us and our editorial standards.