Lara Spencer's Best Thrifting Tips

The antiquing expert and Everything But the House host spills all her best thrifting tips — and, of course, they're good.

May 12, 2022

Related To:

We know Lara Spencer loves thrifting. We watched the Good Morning America host mentor HGTV's Flea Market Flip contestants as they ravaged for flip-worthy, hidden jewels back in 2012. Now, she’s the host and executive producer of HGTV’s Everything But the House, where she helps homeowners make money off antiques buried in their homes.

Lara’s thrifting expertise goes all the way back — we mean she was cruising flea markets from the comfort of her baby bassinet. “My mom loves the thrill of the hunt, so she’d pack me up in a stroller and take me with her,” says Lara. “Back then, we did it because we didn’t have a lot of money, but it’s still a hobby we can't get enough of.”

Today, Lara visits yard sales, thrift shops and flea markets weekly, chasing the magic feeling that is finding a unique and once-cherished item. Her favorite spots in New York City range from the Salvation Army to Housing Works, and she’s always prepared to get down and dirty with her search. “It’s addicting,” she says. “You never know when you’ll stumble upon a one-of-a-kind treasure."

In honor of season 2 of Everything but the House — coming to HGTV on May 28 at 9/8c — we sat down with Lara to get her tips on how to be a successful thrift shopper. Of course, she had all the answers.

Map Out the Markets, Yard Sales or Shops You Want to Hit

Having a plan makes all the difference. Back in the day, Lara and her mom would scour newspapers in search of appealing-looking yard sales, then physically map out all their stops before leaving the house. “Now we do it all online,” says Lara, who, when she doesn’t have all day to shop, enjoys the spontaneity of popping into a thrift store spur-of-the-moment if she happens to have 15 minutes to spare.

Make a List of Items You’re Interested In

This will sharpen your search. Once you have a list of items, you’ll know exactly what to look for upon arrival at your chosen yard sale, thrift shop, flea market, etc. But, Lara stresses, you don’t have to stick to your list completely. Her best advice for finding the good stuff: “Keep an open mind.” Lara has a knack for buying home accessories and even furniture without knowing exactly where it’ll go.

Scan the Larger Space Before Honing In on Smaller Items

“It’s all about conditioning your eyes,” says Lara. Oftentimes, people donate in bulk, so chances are if you see one gem, others are near — you just may have to do some digging to find it.

Give It Two Laps

Take your time, but more importantly, “trust your gut,” says Lara. If you’ve done a couple laps and nothing’s sparking your interest, don’t linger. An extra-thorough (but efficient) look-through always does the trick.

Know the Colors and Patterns You Like

For Lara it’s kelly green and pink — not necessarily together. “If I pass a woman's clothing rack and see kelly green, I'll always pull it out,” says Lara. When it comes to home accessories she can’t pass up the color pink. “If you don’t know what you like or what you’re looking for, start with color,” she says.

Don’t Give Up

Why not check your local thrift shop? It’s sustainable, exciting and affordable. If you don’t find anything, check back next month. “Thrift shops and flea markets are ever-changing kaleidoscopes of treasures,” says Lara. “That’s the fun of it. You never know what you're going to get.”

Season 2 of Everything But the House premieres May 28 at 9/8c on HGTV. Stay up to date with show info on Follow Lara on Instagram at @lara.spencer.

Next Up

Lara Spencer Talks 'Everything But the House,' Thrifting and How to Turn Clutter Into Cash

We’re gearing up for season 2 of Everything But the House, and host Lara Spencer is giving us all the thrifty details on what we have to look forward to.

Discovery+ Greenlights Renovation Romp 'Trixie Motel' Starring Drag Royalty Trixie Mattel

Drag superstar Trixie Mattel, who has taken the world by storm with her outrageous sense of humor and vivacious, retro-kitschy style, is venturing into uncharted waters with newly greenlighted discovery+ series, Trixie Motel.

Jennifer Todryk — aka The Rambling Redhead — Is Coming to HGTV!

Tearing down the notion that major demolition is always necessary to create whole-home transformations, HGTV has picked up 10 one-hour episodes of No Demo Reno (wt), starring home renovation expert and social media influencer Jennifer Todryk.

7 Things to Know About Kim Wolfe of HGTV’s ‘Why The Heck Did I Buy This House?’

She won season 24 of Survivor, and now she's host of the new HGTV show Why the Heck Did I Buy This House? We sat down with Kim Wolfe to learn more.

Anthony Anderson Will Make a Guest Appearance on ‘Extreme Makeover: Home Edition’

It’s been a minute since our last extreme announcement, but we’re coming in hot with some exciting news today: Anthony Anderson is going extreme!

6 Reasons to Be Excited About 'Home Again With the Fords'

You'll laugh, you'll cry, you'll drool at Leanne and Steve's epic renovations.

Lance Bass Visited the ‘Brady Bunch House’ and Had the Best Time

The self-proclaimed superfan, and his husband Michael, toured the home which HGTV meticulously replicated to match the original set design of ‘The Brady Bunch.'

Dave and Jenny Marrs Have a New Spin-Off: 'Fixer to Fabulous: Welcome Inn'

Watch as Jenny and Dave Marrs renovate an old home, with the hopes of turning it into an inn. Fixer to Fabulous: Welcome Inn comes to HGTV on March 15.

It's True, We Bought 'The Brady Bunch' House

Groovy things are happening over here.

Stream discovery+

Your favorite shows, personalities and exclusive originals. All in one place.

Subscribe Now

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.

Luxury Home Giveaways

HGTV Urban Oasis

A bold remodel in Portland, Maine.

HGTV Dream Home

A grand coastal escape located in Newport, Rhode Island.

HGTV Smart Home

A sophisticated home blending design with today’s top tech in Naples, FL.