How to Make a DIY Terra-Cotta Pumpkin Jack-O'-Lantern

Terra-cotta pumpkins make for pretty autumn decor, but they also cost a pretty penny to buy. Luckily, we’ve got you covered with this easy and inexpensive Pottery Barn DIY dupe.

Terra-cotta jack o' lanterns are a stylish, modern twist on classic Halloween decor. The natural, organic vibes of terra cotta lend a subdued tone to a traditionally garish holiday. This handcrafted look is easy to replicate with just a few materials for a fraction of the price.

Photo by: Jennie Andrews

Jennie Andrews

Tools and Materials:

  • spray paint
  • craft paint
  • sponge brushes
  • paintbrush

1. Spackle

While this tutorial uses a plastic pumpkin, the same technique can also be used on other materials, such as ceramic or even glass. First, rough up the surface of your pumpkin with a sanding block or piece of sandpaper. If the plastic is shiny, aim to remove all of the shine. This step is important because it will help the spackle and paint adhere. Using a spackle knife, scoop spackle (we prefer the kind that starts purple and dries white) out of the tub and onto the pumpkin. Use the knife or your fingers to smear the spackle all over the pumpkin. The pumpkin doesn’t need to be totally covered. The goal is to create a less perfect and slightly textured surface that mimics the look of terra cotta. The sharp edges around the nose and mouth especially benefit from the spackle. Use it to slightly alter the shape of the edges so the openings aren’t entirely uniform. Let the spackle dry completely overnight.

2. Sand and Seal

Use a sanding block with a very fine grit (220 is best) to gently sand the spackle. Remove any rough spots or ridges. The surface should be smooth to the touch and the eye but with some variation in dimension. Be very gentle around the openings, taking caution not to knock off any of the spackle. Brush all spackle dust from the surface, then spray the entire surface with an almond- or ivory-colored flat spray paint. This seals in the spackle and acts as a primer for paint.

3. Paint

Use a mix of light orange, terra cotta, ivory and white craft paints. Mix the colors together as you paint. First, apply the paint with a brush and then blend thoroughly by dabbing with a sponge brush made primarily for stenciling. Continue brushing and blending until you don’t see individual colors, just slight variations in shade. Paint the stem in the same manner, but with mostly light-brown paint. Allow the paint to dry completely.

4. Spackle Wash

In a cup, mix a small amount of water and spackle at about a 1:1 ratio. Paint the mixture lightly onto the pumpkin. Allow it to fully dry and your pumpkin will be left with a light, matte haze. If you applied a bit too much in places, you can sand it away gently.

5. Make a Full Patch

These terra-cotta pumpkins are so easy, fun to make AND affordable, you’ll surely want to make enough for a whole pumpkin patch. Small ones look great adorning a mantel or entry table (pumpkins without faces would even make a beautiful Thanksgiving centerpiece), while large ones are a perfect addition to a festive autumn porch.

Photo by: Jennie Andrews

Jennie Andrews

Next Up

How to Make a 'Broomba': A Robot Vacuum Turned Into a Halloween Witch’s Broom

Turn your robotic vacuum into the life of your Halloween party by transforming it into a self-moving witch's broom.

Create Upcycled Halloween Planters Using Leftover Creepy-Crawly Toys

Toy worms, bats and spiders are put to good use in this arguably super-cute, Halloween embossed planter.

Fall For This Quirky DIY Pumpkin Gnome

Our no-carve pumpkin gnome is an easy fall DIY that is quick to assemble and sure to add a touch of whimsy to your autumn decor.

DIY Easter Egg Bunny Gnomes

It’s time to hop into some spring crafting. Use everyday craft materials and a sheet of moss to turn a plain paper mache egg into an adorable Easter Bunny gnome.

How to Make Giant Spiderwebs for Halloween

The secret to great-looking Halloween spiderweb decorations? Beef netting — the kind butchers use to wrap meats. It easily stretches to cover any surface, and it's durable so you can use it year after year. Just don’t forget the giant spiders.

Halloween Decor: How to Make Glowing Specimen Jars

Brighten your Halloween decorations with these neon-green, glowing jars that look like they came straight out of a mad scientist's laboratory.

Make These DIY Specimen Jars to Liven Up Your Creepy Halloween Decor

Be your own Frankenstein and create this spine-tingling decor with water, calcium chloride, sodium-alginate powder and food coloring.

Craft a Clay Incense House Burner

Keep your house smelling oh-so-fresh all season long by crafting an incense-burning house out of oven-bake clay.

DIY Outdoor Halloween Decoration: Illuminated Life-Size Witch

Light up your yard and greet trick-or-treaters with this easy-to-make, lovely lady.

How to Make a Gumball Machine Pumpkin

With a little patience (and a whole lot of gumballs), you can create a one-of-a-kind decor piece that trick-or-treaters will flock to this Halloween.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.