Cookie Cutter Peppermint Fudge

Cookie cutters aren't just great for baking, they also make a cute container for decadent fudge before packaging it up as a homemade holiday gift. 

Cookie Cutter Fudge

Cookie Cutter Fudge

These cookie cutters filled with fudge make great handmade Christmas gifts.

Photo by: Heather Baird

Heather Baird

Materials Needed

non-stick cooking spray
5 cookie cutters (about 3” each)
aluminum foil
1 cup (about 6 ounces) semisweet chocolate chips
1/2 cup extra crunchy peanut butter
crushed peppermint candy (or other topping if you prefer, like chopped salted peanuts or pretzel or toffee pieces)
disposable piping bag or zip-top bag
6x9” cellophane bag
colorful ribbon

Yield: About 5 gifts

Prep Cookie Cutters

Lightly spray a 6 to 8” piece of aluminum foil with cooking spray and lay a cookie cutter in the center (Image 1).  Fold and scrunch the foil tightly around the edges of the cookie cutter (Image 2). Smooth the foil flat on the inside of the cutter using a finger. Lay the prepared cutters on a baking tray (Image 3).

Prep Fudge

Combine the chocolate chips and peanut butter in a bowl (Image 1) and heat in the microwave at 30 second intervals until the mixture can be stirred smooth, about 1 minute 30 seconds. Let the mixture cool slightly.

Photo by: Heather Baird

Heather Baird

Fill Cookie Cutters

Transfer the candy to a disposable piping bag (or zip-top bag) with the tip snipped (Image 1). Pipe candy into the cookie cutters and shake the pan gently to level the candy (Image 2). Sprinkle candy with crushed peppermint or other desired toppings (Image 3). Transfer to the refrigerator to chill, about 30 minutes to 1 hour.

Remove Foil

Remove foil from the backs of the cookie cutters. If any candy has seeped to the outside, gently wipe it away with a paper towel.

Photo by: Heather Baird

Heather Baird

Package Gifts

Place the cutters in a 6x9” cellophane bag (Image 1) and tie with festive ribbon.  Add fun gift tags if desired (Image 2). Tip: If making these ahead, store them packaged in the refrigerator for longevity.

Next Up

How to Make a Christmas Cat Spinner Wand

In all of the gifting during the holidays, don't forget about your furry friends. This holly-themed cat toy is easy to make and will encourage hours of playful interaction.

How to Make a Christmas Catnip Toy

Don't forget your furry best friend when making handmade gifts for the holidays. With just basic sewing skills, you can whip up a catnip-filled stocking-shaped toy as a surprise for your favorite kitty.

Gooey Chocolate Crinkle Cookies Recipe

Delight chocoholics on your gift list with these soft-centered cookies that are a snap to bake.

Peppermint Bark Chocolate Cookies Recipe

Combining two popular holiday flavors – peppermint and chocolate – these tasty cookies are perfect for gift giving.

Edible Christmas Ornament Cookie Pops

Festive and oh-so-tasty, these colorful ornament cookie pops are almost too pretty to eat -- almost!

Cranberry Orange Linzer Cookies Recipe

Sweet and tart, these sandwich cookies combine two favorite seasonal flavors and are as pretty as they are tasty.

Chirstmas Classic: Pecan Bourbon Balls Recipe

It’s hard to beat a classic! Bourbon balls are traditional Christmas treats that make wonderful homemade gifts. This version is made with ground pecans, but ground walnuts can be substituted in equal amounts. For a festive finishing touch, display and serve them in paper cones made from decorative card stock.

Mini Rum Bundt Cakes With Butter-Rum Glaze

These mini Bundt cakes are well-doused in aged rum, and covered in delicious cinnamon hard sauce. They’ll be a welcome sight on any holiday table. Display the cakes on sprigs of fresh rosemary and garnish with cranberries to give them festive holiday color. These cakes can be packaged individually in gusseted treat bags for gift-giving.

Homemade Treat: Snowman Chocolate Bark

Delicious, adorable and easy to whip up even for a big group of people, these sweet snowmen will delight everyone on your Christmas gift list. 

Edible Ornaments: Make Monogrammed Shortbread Christmas Cookies

These personalized shortbread ornaments can double as holiday place cards or Christmas party favors. Simple letter stencils can be found at most any craft store. Plan ahead because the royal icing on these cookies needs to dry for at least four hours or overnight.

More from:

Handmade Holidays

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.