Bring Old and New Together in a Renovation

Updating historic homes for today's lifestyles creates both challenges and opportunities.
Victorian interior with antique lamps

TS-200361609-001_victorian-home-interior_s4x3

Victorian interior with antique lamps

Photo by: Kim Steele

Kim Steele

By: Chuck Ross

When renovating a period home, one question is almost sure to arise: what to keep old and what to make new. Owners are often drawn to period details, but they may find smaller, old-style proportions constricting. Certainly 100-plus-year-old bathrooms and kitchens were not designed with today's lifestyles in mind. Also, if the renovation involves an addition, contractors and homeowners will need to decide just how seamless the exterior visual transition between the original and new structures should be.

Taking a Practical Approach

"When we started in the business, we were ultra-traditionalist, but we've become more open," says Jonathan Bell, who, with his wife, Heather, is owner of Richmond, Va.-based Old Homes Inc. The company has renovated more than 40 residential and commercial properties in Tennessee, Georgia and Virginia. "With kitchens, we go modern. And we'll typically take one bathroom and make it historic style, and then we may do one bathroom that's more untraditional."

Kitchens and bathrooms are the biggest targets for more-modern makeovers. Period living and dining rooms can be almost like works of art, with their layers of crown molding and built-in shelving, and homeowners generally see value in restoring rather than replacing these areas. But period kitchens can be boxy and difficult areas for modern cooks to maneuver in. And the bathroom as we know it — complete with toilet, tub and sink — didn't exist in many homes 100 years ago, so any bath in a house that age or older is likely to be a patched-together affair — and show it.

There are tricks to making sure updated space doesn't appear as though it were simply dropped into an old house. Michael Menn, co-owner of Northbrook, Ill.-based Design Construction Concepts Ltd., says he carries materials and trim styles that are similar to the original house into the new space to help provide visual continuity.

Similarly, Doug Hanna, a partner in Cambridge, Mass.-based S&H Construction, Inc., may pair traditional wood, slate or soapstone countertops, which provide a feeling of history, with unabashedly modern, stainless-steel appliances in a wide-open space of contemporary proportions.

However, there are certain design elements that Hanna prefers to refurbish and reuse, regardless of the overall style. Because these pieces were generally cut from old-growth timber, he says, they withstand the elements better than today's second-growth materials.

"A lot of these things may look worn, but they've held up over the years," he says, comparing the tight, weather-resistant graining of yesterday's wood to today's more open-grained offerings. "With a coat of paint and a little attention it will probably hold up better."

An Outside View

While the blending of old and new interiors raises practical questions, the issues are often more philosophical with exterior renovations, especially when an addition is involved. Professional opinions differ as to just how easy it should be to tell where an original structure ends and new construction begins.

"My personal opinion is that it should not look like an addition, especially in an historic home," says Menn of Design Construction Concepts. "I've seen some juxtapositions where they've put a contemporary addition on a more traditional home. They look nice, but it's just not my style."

Next Up

The Pros and Cons of Buying a Fixer-Upper, According to The Brownstone Boys

Jordan Slocum and Barry Bordelon, The Brownstone Boys, started a new chapter together in 2018 when the NYC couple decided to purchase a 130-year-old Brooklyn brownstone. They quickly caught the fixer-upper bug and started a blog to document their salvage saga, which later grew into an online community and successful restoration business. Order their new book, For the Love of Renovating: Tips, Tricks & Inspiration for Creating Your Dream Home, find out if a fixer-upper is right for you, and gather inspiration for your next home makeover.

Galey Alix's Latest Design Renovation Inspired the Cutest Reaction From a 4-Year-Old

The 'Home in a Heartbeat' host is an influencer to all, even the little ones

HGTV Now Casting for a New Orange County, CA Home Renovation Show

We’re looking to help homeowners in Orange County, CA, with any long-overdue renovations.

Emergency Restoration Experts and Sisters Star in HGTV's New Show 'Renovation 911'

Property disasters are no match for Minneapolis-based sisters Lindsey Uselding and Kirsten Meehan. Here's all the details on their new HGTV show Renovation 911.

25 Brands You Didn’t Know You Can Shop on Amazon

Take advantage of fast, free shipping — and returns — while still buying our favorite bedding and linens, appliances, kitchenware and more.

Talk to a Toolman: Q&A With Chip Wade

Should you hire a pro or do that home repair yourself? HGTV Magazine asks Elbow Room’s Chip Wade to weigh in on five common questions.

How to Clean Your Cellphone

Remove bacteria from your phone with these simple steps.

Quick Tips for Home Organization

Try these quick home organization tips for maintaining a clutter-free home from basement to attic.

Swedish Death Cleaning: It's Not as Grim as You Might Think

Okay, a little less grim. But a lot less grime.

Here's How Chelsea DeBoer Landed a Show on HGTV

The Teen Mom 2 star totally manifested HGTV's Down Home Fab — and she has the receipts to prove it.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

On TV

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.