How to Make Pie-in-a-Jar Party Favors

Give Thanksgiving guests an extra reason to give thanks by sending them home with their very own hand-held treats. This apple pie-in-a-jar recipe is seasonal, simple and the just the right amount for satisfying a holiday sweet tooth.
Apple Pie in a Jar Party Favors

Apple Pie in a Jar Party Favors

Give Thanksgiving guests an extra reason to give thanks by sending them home with their very own hand-held treats. This apple pie-in-a-jar recipe is seasonal, simple and the just the right amount for satisfying a holiday sweet tooth.

Related To:

Materials Needed:

  • small Mason jars
  • 5" circular pastry cutter
  • 3" circular pastry cutter
  • small heart-shaped cutter (can be purchased at any craft store)
  • pie crust pastry, chilled (homemade or store-bought)
  • homemade or store-bought pie filling (we used apple)
  • tan card stock
  • scissors
  • white gel pen
  • 1/4"-wide satin ribbon

Cut Pie Crust

Clear workspace and roll out pastry dough (Image 1). Using larger circular crust cutter, cut 5-inch circle out of pastry (Image 2).

Fill Jars

Carefully place crust in glass jar; use your fingers to press dough against jar's walls (Image 1). Spoon pie filling into dough-lined jar (Image 2).

Cut Pie Top

On new sheet of pastry, use 3-inch circular pastry cutter to cut out top crust (Image 1). Tip: Use cutter with crimped edges for added decorative detail. Use a heart-shaped cutter to punch an air hole in the top crust circle (Image 2).

Seal Then Bake

Place crust on top of filled jar. Use fingers or fork to tightly pinch edges of top crust to bottom crust to seal (Image 1). Bake pie for 20-25 minutes at 350 degrees F (Image 2). Remove pie from oven and set aside to cool (Image 3).

Create Lid and Embellish

While pie is baking, trace circumference of Mason jar top onto card stock and cut out (Images 1 and 2). Write holiday wishes on card-stock circle. Once pie cools, place circle on Mason jar top and twist outer ring onto jar top to secure (Image 3). Finally, tie a ribbon around each favor before distributing to guests (Image 4).

Next Up

Hot Spiked Cocoa Recipe

Knock the chill off outdoor holiday activities with this tasty twist on homemade hot cocoa. Kahlua, light rum or silver tequila will give it an extra kick.

Hot Apple-Ginger Toddy Recipe

Apple cider, bourbon and candied ginger combine to create a flavorful twist on the classic hot toddy.

Thanksgiving Kids' Craft: Turkey Cupcakes

Kids of all ages will have a blast using candy and frosting to dress up plain cupcakes to resemble cute Thanksgiving turkeys. Make these treats a day before the big feast or make decorating the cupcakes part of your Turkey Day festivities.

Hot Hard Apple Cider Recipe

Greet Thanksgiving guests coming in from the cold with this warm, richly scented hard apple cider.

Thanksgiving Kids' Craft: Foam Turkeys

Foam balls, googly eyes, paint and colorful paper straws are all you need to help kids craft these cute turkey decorations for Thanksgiving.

Irish Coffee Recipe

Irish whisky and a dollop of whipped cream are all you need to turn a cup of coffee into this cold-weather classic. This drink isn't overly rich so it pairs well with dessert yet is tasty enough to serve on its own.

Roast Turkey With Lemon and Sage

Seasoned with fresh sage, white wine and lemon, this turkey recipe gives a succulent, citrus twist to the star of your Thanksgiving dinner.

Pumpkin Pancakes With Vanilla Bourbon Maple Syrup

Fall for autumn's favorite flavor - pumpkin - with this recipe for fluffy, flavorful pumpkin pancakes topped with homemade maple syrup. Perfect for a Thanksgiving brunch or as an anytime breakfast treat.

How to Brine a Turkey

Dry turkey is a thing of the past with this recipe for garden herb and apple cider brine.

Day After Thanksgiving Soup Recipe

Use turkey day leftovers in a spectacular soup.
More from:

Thanksgiving Ideas

What's New in Handmade

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.

Related Pages