HGTV Dream Home 2015: Building Challenges and Solutions

Meet the challenges posed by time restrictions, island accessibility and design style.
HGTV Dream Home 2015 located on Martha's Vineyard in Edgartown, MA. Ineterior view of kitchen facing back patio.

Commissioned Photographer

View of the front of the HGTV Dream Home 2015 located on Martha's Vineyard in Edgartown, MA

By: Peter Walsh

There are sure to be challenges when building any new home but with careful planning, the Dream Home on Martha's Vineyard basically went up without any problems.

Building and Time Restrictions

First, the Field Club community has its own restrictions as to what a new home in the area should look like. You will not see an early 18th century style home sitting next to a modern style home in this neighborhood.

The reason people visit, buy or build here is because of the classic New England homes. Over the years, all of the Dream Home designs have been appropriate to the area.
House Planner Jack Thomasson 

Instead, the homes are similar to one another in their classic architectural design and materials. "You could build a more contemporary home on the island," says Jack Thomasson, the professional house planner who worked on the project. "But the reason people visit, buy or build here is because of the classic New England homes. Over the years, all of the Dream Home designs have been appropriate to the area they are located in."

To head off any potential issues, Thomasson interviewed and hired local contractors, who are familiar with the construction practices on the island, to build the house according to the plans drawn up by lead architect, Patrick Ahearn. "The biggest challenge was time," says Thomasson. "Building a house like this would normally take a year but we had to do it five months."

To that end, local contractor, Tim McHugh, owner of Timothy McHugh Builders, Inc., Edgartown, Massachusetts, who grew up on the island, had to get busy fast. "Everybody wants to be in his or her homes in the summer," he says. "So we had to hire the subcontractors in the fall to get them to work in the spring." That includes the carpenters, electricians, masons, plumbers, plasterers and painters.

Getting Around Martha's Vineyard

Once the house plans were finalized, McHugh ordered the windows and doors even before the contract was written. "Otherwise, we would have been behind schedule," he said. He also used on-island companies to provide the building materials for both inside and outside the home. "They have the supplies we needed," he says. And, because the home is located on an island only accessible by ferry from the mainland, any materials that had to be trucked in required at least a weeks time for planning to reserve a space on the ferry.

According to Patrick Ahearn, while there are about 18,000 year round residents on the island, in the summer months, that number swells to about 180,000 residents in the summer months, all vying for a spot on the ferries for their cars. More and more, people are arriving earlier in the year and leaving later. "Many come in April and stay through Christmas," says Ahearn, thus the extended season means even more traffic and less space on the boats for trucks loaded with building supplies.

Finding the Right Style

Inside the house, the Linda Woodrum, the interior designer on the project, had her own challenges. While most of the furniture, rugs, window treatments and lighting were already sourced, she still had to choose styles that would appeal to more tastes than just those looking for a beach community look.

While the look she was striving for was informed by the classic architecture of the house, it had to have a broader appeal. "There are lots of different types of people and styles," she explains. "We had to have a very broad appeal that suits everybody." Among the many styles, she selected furniture with clean, simple lines in matte gray finishes for the wood pieces such as dining tables and chairs, bedroom furniture and living room furniture accent pieces.

Mixing and Matching

Accessories were added to the main furnishings that would ultimately give the rooms a style that looks like objects were collected over time.

It's not your grandmothers furniture.
Interior Designer Linda Woodrum

"They have a driftwood feel," she says. "It's not your grandmothers furniture." By shopping locally in the brick and mortar stores on the island, she was able to add some accessories to the main furnishings that would ultimately give the rooms a style that looks like objects were collected over time rather than scooped up all at once in one store. "We had to make it as beautiful and as welcoming as we could," says Thomasson. As a giveaway house, he added, they don't know who the winner is going to be so it had to appeal to many.

Next Up

HGTV Dream Home 2025 Winner Announcement

Meet the lucky winner of HGTV Dream Home® 2025 located in Bluffton, South Carolina!

HGTV Dream Home 2023 Winner Announcement

Meet the lucky winner of HGTV Dream Home 2023 in Morrison, CO.

Kitchen From HGTV Dream Home 2016

A mix of classic black and white combined with traditional design details and high-end appliances anchors this open concept kitchen.

Master Bathroom From HGTV Dream Home 2011

Light tile, pine floors and neutral bathroom fixtures and accessories step back and let amazing mountain views steal the show.

HGTV Dream Home 2017 Winner Announcement

HGTV host Tiffany Brooks surprised grand prize winner Anna Spangler of Kutztown, PA, in front of family and friends. See her priceless reaction as she learns the good news.

Pool Lounge From HGTV Dream Home 2017

A chic lounge, wet bar, and bathroom bathed in blue hues create the perfect space for indoor and outdoor entertaining. 

Front Courtyard From HGTV Dream Home 2016

Giant royal palm trees and Florida-friendly plants soften the landscape in the front yard, where an inviting facade is inspired by Mediterranean and Caribbean design.

Backyard From HGTV Dream Home 2017

An expansive backyard with breathtaking water views offers plenty of space for lounging by the pool, dining alfresco, or enjoying a fire pit. 

Guest Bedroom From HGTV Dream Home 2011

This sleek space accommodates overnight guests and offers a picturesque view of the mountaintops.

Ski Dorm From HGTV Dream Home 2011

This colorful ski dorm, which accommodates up to eight guests and makes use of a saturated color palette, offers both privacy and entertainment opportunities.

On TV

Go Shopping

Refresh your home with stylish products handpicked by HGTV editors.

Meet the Experts

Learn about the design and build team responsible for HGTV Dream Home 2026.

Designer: Brian Patrick Flynn

Builder: Knotts Builders, Michael Knotts

More Ways to Win

Browse Our Sweepstakes

We're giving away awesome prizes year-round.

HGTV Smart Home

A sophisticated home with top tech in San Antonio, Texas