Home Town: A House Too Big to Move?

Ben and Erin may have bitten off more than they can chew when they take on a project for a client who wants to move and then renovate her great-grandmother's 1930s home. Sometimes it’s good to have a ‘Plan B’.

Related To:

As seen on Home Town, Hosts Ben and Erin Napier in the dining room of the Rahaim residence. (portrait)

Erin and Ben Napier at the newly renovated Rahaim house

Photo by: Todd Douglas/ Verbatim

Todd Douglas/ Verbatim

Erin and Ben Napier at the newly renovated Rahaim house

What happens when you own a house, but somebody else has bought the land that it's sitting on? For Robyn and Cassidy Rahaim, there's just one answer. Lift the house of the ground and move it. Oh, and get Ben and Erin Napier help with the move then let them renovate the house. Simple, right? Maybe. Maybe not.

The Simmons-Rahain house has been in the Robyn Simmons family for decades on Home Town

Robyn's family home will have to be moved if it's to be saved.

Robyn's family home will have to be moved if it's to be saved.

The Players and The Challenge

Here's the situation: Robyn and Cassidy are newly married and have a five-year-old daughter. The land that had been Robyn's family farm had been sold, however the new owner didn't want the house, just the land. Consequently, the house was set to be torn down. Not willing to see the family home vanish into nothing, Robyn had a plan. "Well, we've got to move it," she said matter-of-factly. "We're keeping it."

The Proviso

The house, which was Robyn's family's original farm house, was built in 1938. It had two bedrooms, 1800 square feet and some desirable features like interior French doors, high bead-board ceilings and hardwood floors. It also had three separate front entrances, a rotting porch and two missing support columns. The cost to move it is $15,000. If that can be done successfully (the big "if"), Robyn and Cassidy's $100,000 budget would leave around $85,000 for renovations. Erin and Ben can take it from there. That's best-case scenario, and Erin has some ideas in mind if things play out as planned.

I mean, that's like the ultimate family heirloom.
Ben Napier

Before

After?

But there are some caveats. Ben and Erin have taken on some fairly intense renovations thus far in Home Town, but nothing like this. Moreover, there are always inherent risks with moving a house, and a myriad of things can potentially go wrong. Some houses don't survive a move. "It's just a little intimidating," understated Erin. "Yeah, I've never moved a house," added Ben, without missing a beat.

They want us to actually pick this house up...relocate this house...and make it beautiful.
Erin Napier

But they're willing to give it a try, but have a backup plan in their back pocket in case of an epic fail. The Plan-B scenario is The Key House, a charming '40s vintage home with some nice vintage features — including one especially important one attribute: it can remain where it is.

As seen on Home Town, Hosts Ben and Erin Napier redesigned the exterior of the Rahaim residence to a craftsman style with large tapered columns to accent the large front porch. (after)

As seen on Home Town, Hosts Ben and Erin Napier redesigned the exterior of the Rahaim residence to a craftsman style with large tapered columns to accent the large front porch. (after)

Photo by: Todd Douglas/ Verbatim

Todd Douglas/ Verbatim

The Transformation

Not to give too much away in terms of where exactly the Rahaim family ends up at the end of of this project, but let's just say that one epic adventure and one collapsed chimney later, renovations can get underway — on a house that's sitting firmly on the ground.

Hosts Ben and Erin Napier level the mantle with precision at the Simmons-Rahaim house on Home Town

Hosts Ben and Erin Napier pause for a behind the scenes look while working on the Simmons-Rahaim house on Home Town

Highlights in the Rahaim's newly re-envisioned home include a massive front porch, bead-board ceilings and beautiful wood floors. There's custom dining table and a vertical-storage dish rack — both a la Scotsman Co. by way of Ben Napier, and an antique bench that Ben salvaged and customized by Ben using reclaimed wood.

Todd Douglas/ Verbatim
Todd Douglas/ Verbatim

As seen on Home Town, Host Ben Napier inspects the bench that he built for the foyer of the Rahaim residence. (action)

As seen on Home Town, Host Erin Napier works in the living room on the final decorations to the fireplace mantle before the reveal of the renovated Rahaim residence. (action)

A refurbished kitchen features bead-board paneling and a painted wood kitchen floor in rust red.

As seen on Home Town, Hosts Ben and Erin Napier watch as homeowner Cassidy (R) shows the work he did on dining table to Robyn (C) Rahaim in the new dining room of their renovated residence. (action)

Ben and Erin with homeowners Robyn (C) and Cassidy (R) in the newly refurbished dining room.

Photo by: Todd Douglas/ Verbatim

Todd Douglas/ Verbatim

The Home Town episode titled "Move It or Lose It" premieres Monday, February 12 at 9p|8c. Check here for additional air times, and check back here to see the full photo gallery, and to see more new galleries, exclusive video and show updates.

Next Up

'Home Town' Tricks: It's So Easy to Pleat With a Fork

On Season 9 of Home Town, co-host Erin Napier and sewist Clayton Boler turn a kitchen staple into a clever pleating tool. Here's how you can put forks to work in your own space.

Ben and Erin Napier Celebrate 10 Years of 'Home Town'

It's been a decade of our favorite Laurel, Mississippi, locals. Let's take a look back at their HGTV journey.

Watch a Sneak Peek: Ben and Erin Napier in Season 10 of 'Home Town'

HGTV is kicking off 2026 the right way. Learn more about the new season of 'Home Town' airing in January.

Inside Ben and Erin Napier’s Enduring Friendship With Jim, Mallorie and Josh of 'Home Town: Inn This Together'

From college days to raising families in Laurel, Mississippi, their connection has only grown stronger over the years.

The Heirloom Hotel Today: Jim, Mallorie and Josh Give an Update

The final moments of ‘Home Town: Inn This Together’ left viewers stunned. After the fire, the owners of the Heirloom Hotel in Laurel, MS, are sharing how they’re coping and what happens next.

The Plate Wall Is Making a Comeback in Southern Design

On Season 3 of Home Town Takeover, co-host Erin Napier revives a vintage-inspired design statement with surprising staying power. Here’s how you can bring it into your home.

'Home Town Takeover': Where Are They Now?

HGTV revisits the now-thriving small town of Wetumpka, Alabama, in a special follow-up to the hit Home Town spinoff, Home Town Takeover, starring Ben and Erin Napier.

Watch a Sneak Peek: Ben and Erin Napier Take Their 'Home Town Takeover' Talents to Florida

Home Town Takeover Season 3 premieres in March. We have all the details.

Erin and Ben Napier Open Up About Filming the 100th Episode of 'Home Town'

The home-renovation power couple, based in Laurel, Mississippi, never imagined the show would make it to this milestone.

On TV

What's New in Shows

Luxury Home Giveaways

HGTV Smart Home

A sophisticated, sporty home in San Antonio, Texas

HGTV Dream Home

A lakeside retreat on Lake Wylie in Charlotte, North Carolina

Follow HGTV on Social

Keep up with HGTV designers and hosts.

About HGTV

HGTV’s expert editors and writers share home decorating, garden and home improvement ideas, inspiration and advice based on our brand’s 30+ years of expertise and experience. We also give you the latest updates on HGTV shows and stars, cleaning tips and shopping recommendations. Learn more about us and our editorial standards.