Sell Your House or Rent It?

Is it smarter to become a landlord than pay a big, fat capital gains tax? Here are the pros and cons of renting and selling your house.
Exterior of Black & White Home With Swing in Tree

Timeless Cape Cod Exterior

A circular drive leads to the entrance of the East Hampton home, complete with a picturesque tree swing in the front yard. Decorative black shutters and crisp white siding is a timeless combination.

By: Tammy Stoner

Before we spin the wheel of house selling, answer this one question: Have you lived in the house you intend to sell at least two of the past five years? If not, you might incur early mortgage payoff penalties and capital gains tax --- two very hefty bills that may make it financially unwise to sell your home. There are ways to avoid capital gains tax --- job change, divorce, death of a spouse, etc., so check with your accountant if you think you might be the exception to this firm rule.

If you have not lived in your home for two of the last five years, or you have the capital to finance another move without selling your home, or if the market is slow in your area, you might want to consider renting. When budgeting for a renter, be sure to include the following costs:

  • Mortgage payment
  • Property tax
  • Homeowner insurance
  • Homeowner association dues (if applicable)
  • Property management company (if applicable)
  • House maintenance

Also, check to be sure your property insurance premiums won’t change if you convert your residence into a rental property. Above all, prepare yourself mentally: Realize this house is no longer your home but your rental property.

Next Up

Buy What You Need, Not What You Want

Make a list of your ideal home and stick to it while house hunting.

Buyers: Don’t Freak Out When You Get Bad Inspection Results

What’s a homebuyer to do if your home inspection has bad results? Drama-Free Real Estate expert Tara-Nicholle Nelson shares her tips and tools.

Building and Ownership Types: Four Degrees of Separation

When buying a house, know the different types of home ownership so you don't miss out on your dream property. Here, a comparison of detached single family residences, PUDs, condos and co-ops.

Buyer's Remorse: Dos and Don’ts for Adjusting Your Mindset

It's common for little worries and wonders to pop up after you've bought your home. Here's how to ease your concerns.

Before You Buy: Answer a Few Tough Questions

Thinking about buying a home? Ask yourself these questions first.

Buying a Home: Don't Forget These Expenses

When deciding how large a down payment you can afford, remember to leave yourself some padding.

Buying a Second Home: Are You Ready?

You'd love to have a second home, sure. But before you start house-hunting, ask yourself these questions.

Buying and Selling Homes With the Market

Learn how to be a savvy seller in both buyer's and seller's markets.

Buyers: What to Do When You Lose Your Job While In Escrow

You're in the middle of buying a home when the dreaded pink slip arrives. Find out how one couple handled the unwelcome turn of events.

Buying a Second Vacation Home in the Tropics

A practical guide to running off to an island.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

About HGTV

HGTV’s expert editors and writers share home decorating, garden and home improvement ideas, inspiration and advice based on our brand’s 30+ years of expertise and experience. We also give you the latest updates on HGTV shows and stars, cleaning tips and shopping recommendations. Learn more about us and our editorial standards.