Landscaping Goofs

Avoiding these common landscaping mistakes will save money and time down the road.
By: Marie Hofer

Related To:

The best garden I've ever had was in my mind's eye — before changing whims, funky soil and various predators have had their say. Still, I'm successfully putting my brand on what had once been an open expanse of lawn. My neighbor was aghast when he saw me plowing large swaths through the front, side and backyards, so I confessed that prim borders aren't my thing. But now when I pull into the driveway after work, the frothy seed heads of various ornamental grasses — positioned where the late afternoon sun backlights them — fill me with joy.

Tiger Lily

Tiger Lily

The late great garden writer Henry Mitchell paid a reasonable amount of attention to texture, form and color in his own garden, but he cared more for the "progress of plants" than being a stickler for design. "If I want a few tiger lilies — as I certainly do — and the best site for them happens to be next to a crimson rose bush, then that's where they go."

Fortunately, gardening is an individualistic sport in which the main goal is to please yourself. And gardeners know that great gardens are a process, not a destination. We can all learn from each other's mistakes, though. Here are a few that come to mind:

Wrong plant in the wrong place.



The previous owner of our home loved dogwoods and planted them throughout the yard. The only problem: the yard is relentlessly hot and sunny all summer. The poor little dogwoods, meant to be understory trees, are struggling to survive. Know the conditions your prospective garden additions are going to want — light, soil, water — before you plant. And as the landscape changes — as it invariably does — note whether you need to move something to a more suitable location.

Subsoil on top.

Builders and developers sometimes carve off the top soil from a site, leaving only the subsoil. "This is No. 1 on my list of landscaping mistakes," says Henry Nunnery, York County Extension Agent in South Carolina. "It means that people then are trying to grow things where it's almost impossible [to do so], and it's sometimes hard to work around." Nunnery suggests that prospective home buyers, when possible, work out an agreement with the builder at the beginning to preserve the top soil or to restore at least six inches of top soil back to the site.

Out of proportion.

A nearby ranch home is all but obliterated from view by two gigantic white pines planted in front of the home. Years ago, these might have started out as cute Christmas trees. Seventy feet later (and 35 feet in width), they give only the slightest glimpse of the home hiding behind their needles. Accommodate the expected mature size of a plant when you plant it. That applies to girth as well: If you're planting broad-beamed trees and shrubs such as dogwoods and large viburnums near the house or driveway, be sure to allow for their eventual expansion. Don't plant them in areas where they won't have room to grow, because many of these trees and shrubs are not meant to be confined to sizes smaller than nature intended.

Topping trees.

Amur Maple Tree

Amur Maple Tree

An amur maple won't take over the landscape.

An amur maple won't take over the landscape.

Many homeowners get sold on the erroneous notion that topping trees saves branch drop and maybe roof damage. The truth is, removing a tree's crown sets the tree up for rapid decay and decline. Plus, the suckers that sprout from the cut trunk are weakly attached and susceptible to breakage--not to mention creating disfigured silhouettes in the wintertime.

If you have to reduce the height of a tree--perhaps because of nearby power lines--consider removing it and planting a smaller tree. There are plenty of wonderful, shorter versions of many of our favorites. Want a maple? Amur maples and paperbark maples make fabulous—and more diminutive—lawn specimens that won't take over the landscape.

Too much busy-ness.

When you're an enthusiastic gardener, it's fun to have one of each thing, but try to congregate your experiments into one area. Or find a way to pull the look together by repeating some of the same colors and plants in other parts of the landscape.

Too much of the same thing.

If you want to camouflage a 200-foot length of a neighbor's chainlink fence, there may be a better way than planting Burford hollies every four feet. Besides being monotonous, too many of the same type of plant sets up a monoculture, which may then become susceptible to an invasion of pests. How much more fun to have a selection of viburnums, hollies, elaeagnus, leucothoe, and other flowering and fruiting shrubs that will provide multi-season interest and feed (or house) the birds.

Planting too deeply.

Tree Planting Backfilling Planting Hole

Planting a Tree

You can plant shrubs and trees right up until the ground freezes, but you’ll have better overwintering in coldest zones if you get plants in before hard frosts arrive. This gives plants an opportunity to strike new roots into soil before serious cold arrives. Remember to water fall planted additions to your landscape until the ground freezes. In regions with mild winters where the ground doesn’t freeze, plan to water new plants through winter during dry spells.

Photo by: Fiskars


A tree needs to have a "basal flare," a widening of the trunk near the ground. If your tree looks more like a telephone pole, it's planted too deeply. Plant all trees and shrubs at the same level as they grew in the nursery. If you dig the planting hole deeper than the root ball (you don't need to), be sure to tamp the soil well as you backfill so that the tree doesn't settle below its ideal planting depth over time.

Grade changes around already established trees can also wreak havoc on a tree's health. Adding as little as six inches of soil — and sometimes even less — on top of what's already there can reduce air circulation, and restrict the movement of water and nutrients. Some species are more susceptible than others. If you must change the grade, call in a certified arborist to help guide the process.

Not taking care of the big issues first.

We can't anticipate every change of heart that will influence our garden plans, but we can try to take care of the biggies. If a retaining wall needs to be built or a new water line laid, best tackle those projects before you do any more planting.

And one of the biggest landscape mistakes, says Nunnery, is not taking care of drainage problems before you plant. "Our soils here are mostly clay, and if the water stands in place, plants get root rot and die — or just not grow. Drainage problems probably kill more plants than anything else." Recontouring your terrain, installing French drains, or simply ditching a problem site can help direct the water where you want it to go.

Next Up

Landscape Zones

Defining and designing landscape zones on your property

Landscaping Pitfalls

Gardening expert Paul James suggests ways to avoid common landscaping and gardening problems.

Hot Landscaping Trends

From low maintenance to bold color, find out what landscape designers are loving in the garden.

Dream Landscape 2009

HGTV's Dream Home 2009 is a beautiful Victorian-style farmhouse in the Sonoma Valley, and its landscape is the perfect complement.

Creating Landscape Windbreaks

Select the right trees and shrubs and locate them properly with these tips.

25 Biggest Landscaping Mistakes

HGTV has brought together some of the best gardening experts to share their insider tips on how to avoid common landscaping disasters and what to do to fix them if it does happen.

Tips for Landscaping a New Home

Ideas for how to make your new house a home.

HGTV Dream Home 2005: Landscape Design

For this lakeside home, the landscape architect turned the property into an outdoor oasis.

Landscape Design Ideas for Every Location

Bring outdoor spaces to life with easy landscape ideas that add curb appeal to your yard, garden, pool and patio.

Landscaping Plants

It’s easy to find landscaping plants and flowers that work well with your yard no matter where you live.

Go Shopping

Spruce up your outdoor space with products handpicked by HGTV editors.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.