Work With Local Historic Commissions When Remodeling

Knowing the rules of preservation groups will smooth the path for future renovation projects.


Photo by:

By: Chuck Ross

Related To:

Location may be the key word in a real estate agent's vocabulary, but it can play just as big a part in a contractor's life when it comes to working with historic houses. Exterior modifications to homes located within locally designated historic districts will require local historic commission approval. And if the house itself is historic, commissioners may be even more demanding with regard to design and materials.

Designation as to what is considered historic can vary from town to town, according to Drane Wilkinson of the National Alliance of Preservation Commissions. While the National Register for Historic Places requires a structure to be at least 50 years old before it can be included on the national registry, links to more recent history can motivate local commissions to declare younger buildings equally significant.

A number of factors can play a role in a commission's decision to declare a structure historic, regardless of age, including:

  • Architectural significance or quality. The structure is a good example of a particular architectural movement or style.
  • Association with a historically important person
  • Association with a historically important event

Additionally, Wilkinson notes, many local commissions are beginning to consider the potential of a structure or site to yield historically important information in the future through archeological findings.

Historic or Not?

Learning whether a structure falls under a local historic commission's jurisdiction is up to the contractor, says David Carpenter who founded a remodeling firm with a specialty in historic restoration. This education begins with a trip to town hall.

Plans to change major exterior design elements will attract especially close scrutiny, Wilkinson notes. Because original windows are both major architectural-style indicators and frequent targets for energy-conscious renovators, they can be a point of contention between contractors and commissions, he says. Commissioners may require contractors take another look at renovating existing windows before approving new-window plans.

"Windows are a big element, because the tendency is to want to rip out old wooden windows, when the truth is you can often rehabilitate the original windows," Wilkinson says.

Using Modern Materials

Moves to incorporate modern materials also can raise commission concern, both Wilkinson and Carpenter say.

"The general rule of thumb is, does it look like the material it's replacing and is it at least as durable as the material it's replacing?" Wilkinson says. "And is it reversible without damaging the building?"

Cement-fiber siding is one synthetic alternative that many commissions are beginning to accept, according to Wilkinson. The question, he says, is how the material is intended to be used such as a spot replacement or to finish an entire addition wall. In many cases, he notes, an entire wall installation would be favored over a spot-replacement job, Wilkinson says.

In all cases, though, he urges contractors to begin conversations with commissioners early in the design and specification process. Such an approach also can help builders catch potential conflicts between a town's historic guidelines and any building codes that may be in force. Building inspectors may be willing to accept some sort of compromise or to make an exception for historic buildings, Carpenter says. But again, the best chance for reaching such an agreement is if you begin having those conversations before you even pull out a crowbar.

Next Up

HGTV Obsessed Episode 9: Ty Pennington

Ty Pennington joins Mike and Kat to talk about his new show Ty Breaker and his role as host on Rock the Block. Then Steve and Leanne Ford share advice on moving vs. renovating.

What Does Asbestos Look Like and How to Identify It

Nearly 50 years after the first federal ban, asbestos is finally not being used in new residential building materials, but it still exists in millions of homes. Living with asbestos doesn’t automatically make it a problem, but it can become one if we’re not careful.

Getting Ready for a Reno? Check Out These Design Resources First

Check out these online tools and apps to help with your renovation.

HGTV Obsessed Episode 35: Jasmine Roth

On this week’s episode, we are talking about when not to DIY with Jasmine Roth. Then Ursula Carmona talks about the top five must-have tools for every DIYer.

Easy Lighting Updates That Will Transform Your Entire Space

We're sharing simple, illuminating ways to update your kitchen, living room and bedroom — no demo required.

Drew And Jonathan Scott Return for Season 7 of 'Property Brothers: Forever Home'

Home renovation stars Drew and Jonathan Scott return for a fresh season of their popular HGTV series, Property Brothers: Forever Home, filmed in their newly adopted hometown of Los Angeles.

Jenny and Dave Marrs Open Their Very Own Store

The space was an old bank until HGTV's Fixer to Fabulous duo got their hands on it. Shopping spree at Marrs Mercantile, anyone?

The ‘Rock the Block’ Season 2 Contestants and Judges Have Been Announced!

HGTV has announced the judges and challengers for the second season of Rock the Block, which is slated to premiere in March 2021.

Get to Know Galey Alix: All the Details on Her New HGTV Show 'Home in a Heartbeat'

Interior design sensation Galey Alix — who captivates millions of followers across TikTok and Instagram with her impressive home transformations — is coming to HGTV in April. We have all the details.

Joe Mazza Returns to HGTV in New Series ‘What's Wrong With That House?’

Home Inspector Joe and designer Noel Gatts are back — and they're ready to jump right back into their fixer-upper ways. Here's what to expect from their new series.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.