Halloween Party Food: Spooky Goat Cheese Fingers

Cheese and crackers take a spooky turn when goat cheese is fashioned to resemble fingers with sliced almonds as fingernails. Pair with whole-wheat crackers and flatbreads for a flavor combo that's sure to appeal to guests of all ages.
Goat Cheese Fingers and Crackers

Spooky Goat Cheese Fingers

Photography by Buff Strickland

Photography by Buff Strickland

Makes 12 "fingers"

Ingredients:

12 ounces plain goat cheese (not crumbles), at room temperature
1 jar roasted red peppers
salt and pepper
1/2 cup sliced almonds
red edible marker (available at craft or specialty baking stores)

Directions:

1. Roughly chop one-quarter cup of jarred roasted red peppers, then combine in a blender or food processor with goat cheese until creamy. Season to taste with salt and pepper. Refrigerate until cold (the cold cheese is easier to work with and will better maintain its shape).

2. Scoop out one tablespoon of goat cheese mixture, then roll into a log that's the length and width of a finger. (A little irregularity is fine, and actually makes each finger look more realistic.) Repeat with remainder of cheese and place fingers on a serving platter.

3. Use a paring knife to score "knuckles" onto the top and middle of each finger (Image 1).

4. Separate out the unbroken almond slices (you'll need one for each finger), then color each one red using an edible marker. Gently press one onto the top of each goat cheese finger to resemble red fingernails.

5. Serve with a cheese knife and assortment of plain and whole-wheat crackers and flatbread.

Using Knife to Make Knuckle Lines on Goat Cheese Fingers

Using Knife to Create Knuckle Lines on Cheese Fingers

Use a paring knife to score "knuckles" onto the top and middle of each finger.

Next Up

The 56 Best Halloween Costumes You Can Order Online

Check out these cute costume ideas for the whole family.

23 Best Pop Culture Halloween Costume Ideas for 2025

Make an entrance (and earn a lot of laughs) with these Halloween costumes inspired by trending moments in TV, music, movies and more in 2025.

PSA: Target's Hyde & EEK! Boutique Is Back, and We Want Everything

Halloween decorations have officially hit the shelves at Target! See their 2026 collection and snag our top picks while supplies last.

20 Best Halloween Countdown Calendars

The countdown to Halloween is on! Start a fun new tradition with these festive calendars.

40+ Last-Minute Halloween Costumes You Can Order Online

Are the holidays sneaking up on you? We've got you covered for the first one to hit the scene — Halloween — with costumes you can get delivered to your home in a matter of days.

Make This Easy-to-Sew Spider Hand Puppet for Halloween

No sewing machine is required for this darling spider hand puppet!

New Shows on HGTV and DIY Network to Watch in October

Count on new episodes of Property Brothers, Rehab Addict and more when spooky Halloween watches get to be too much.

This Year's Best HGTV Halloween Costumes

Are y'all ready to see some awesomely creative Fixer Upper and Property Brothers Halloween costumes?

Sweet and Salty Halloween Snack Mix

Halloween guests big and small will love this crunchy snack mix that combines everyone's favorite flavors and textures. Package the mix in small paper bags to give away as party favors or as a treat for your favorite door-to-door ghosties.

Marshmallow Jack-o'-Lantern Cookies

These little jack-o'-lanterns are as cute as they are tasty. Placed on a chocolate wafer for crunch, these soft marshmallows can be made several days ahead of your Halloween party. But they're so irresistible, you'll need to hide them.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

On TV

About HGTV

HGTV’s expert editors and writers share home decorating, garden and home improvement ideas, inspiration and advice based on our brand’s 30+ years of expertise and experience. We also give you the latest updates on HGTV shows and stars, cleaning tips and shopping recommendations. Learn more about us and our editorial standards.