The Best Valentine's Day Gifts You Can Buy on Etsy

Shop small and spoil big with these custom gift ideas from some of our favorite Etsy creators.

Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money off these affiliate links. Learn more.
January 11, 2024

Valentine’s Day is widely associated with romantic relationships, but we think February 14th offers the perfect opportunity to show everyone some much-needed love. And what better way to celebrate your parent, bestie, nephew or life partner than with a thoughtful, personalized gift? We’ve curated an Etsy gift list for all the special people in your life so that you can spoil your Valentine and support small businesses in one fell swoop. Find everything you need to play Cupid in the links below.

$29.99 $22
Etsy | OakdeneDesigns
On Sale!

Looking for a budget-friendly gift for your new flame or long-time love? Add this personalized couple’s matchbox to your Etsy cart now, and thank us later. The charming token is visually stunning and comes customized with your names for a sentimental touch. But, the best part? Each box includes 20 oversized wooden matches scribed with fun and unexpected date ideas that promise to keep you entertained, day or night. Pro tip: Pair your custom box with a scented candle (because who doesn’t love a good candle?) and a free evening to jumpstart your match date journey.

From $21.50
Etsy | PlainInkDiary

Prepare for your sentimental sweetheart to swoon over this thoughtful Valentine’s gift. This personalized linen hardcover photo album is the best gift for the partner who serves as the self-appointed recorder of your relationship, capturing shared milestones and all the sweet, stolen moments in between with their Instax Mini. The hardcover album holds 256 mini photos, is available in six neutral linen finishes and features a personalized front and spine with your choice of 12 unique cover motifs. Choose from five lettering colors, including metallic rose, gold and silver, to round out your custom album design.

24 Best Mother's Day Gifts on Etsy

May brings flowers and a time to celebrate all the moms in our village. Shower them with these handmade and personalized gifts.

$55 $50
Etsy | NorMorGifts
On Sale!

Show your mom how much you adore her on Valentine’s Day with this cozy curated gift box. Each indulgent set comes with a white ribbed mug, a plush throw blanket, gourmet cookies, fuzzy socks, luxury shea butter lotion, tea or latte mix, a gold tea spoon and a charming greeting card of your choice.

Etsy | LifetimeLeatherCo

How do you spoil the guy who never really wants or needs anything for Valentine’s Day? Treat him to an elevated everyday item with a sentimental touch. This timeless toiletry bag is built to last and guaranteed to please with its durable, genuine leather design, classic silhouette and personalized engraved detail. Each bag boasts a waterproof waxed nylon lining and comes in three sizes to offer ample space for his essentials at home or on the go. Choose between seven striking leather finishes and give the Dopp a custom touch with your choice of firebrand or embroidered initials. And, if you really want to up the ante — add a little love note woven into the interior lining to remind him how much he means to you as he digs around for his contacts case each morning.

Etsy | Leathergoods43

Treat them to a special spot to store their spectacles with this handsome leather glasses case. The sleek case comes in five stains and is handcrafted in Spain using traditional leatherwork techniques. Each case features a rigid exterior to protect spectacles while on the go and is customizable with up to six initials.

From $8.74
Etsy | BusyPuzzle
On Sale!

Gift your littlest sweetheart this custom and eco-friendly name puzzle. The keepsake puzzle is handcrafted from plywood and painted in a color palette of your choice to reflect your little one’s nursery or playroom. This puzzle was created by a mother for tots ages three and below to help build motor skills, develop color recognition and learn how to spell their name.

Etsy | TwoTmbleweeds

Treat your partner to the gift of adventurous and oh-so-delicious homecooked meals with this Foodie Dice set. Each set comes with four seasonal vegetable dice and five primary dice that offer choices for protein, cooking method, grain/carb, herb and bonus ingredients. To play, you and your partner simply select the current season of vegetable dice and roll it along with the five, primary dice. Use the selections left face-up after your roll to build your grocery list and whip up an unexpected and delicious date night at home.

From $69
Etsy | GLDNxLayeredAndLong

Show your lovely lady how much she means to you with this dainty personalized ring. The minimalist wrap design comes in sterling silver, yellow gold fill or rose gold fill to best suit your sweetheart’s style. Each ring is handmade and comes with a custom, hand-engraved inscription of your choice. Not sure how to personalize her ring? Use Roman numerals to mark an extra-special anniversary date, add both of your first initials or spell out your Valentine’s first name with a tiny heart.

From $58
Etsy | HitherRabbit

Leave your Valentine grinning ear-to-ear with this custom embroidery hoop pet portrait. The charming design is handmade using a wooden embroidery hoop, herringbone cotton fabric and eco-friendly fabric ink. Each design also comes with an option to have the subject’s name embroidered for an added personal touch. Bonus: The artist works exclusively with neutral colors to ensure the portrait fits well with any interior.

From $30.60
Etsy | Gladfolk

Looking for the perfect token of love for your Galentine? Make her day with this sweet, customized cutting board. The airy wood board comes with an engraved floral motif that surrounds an optional name and date personalization. Scoop up the charming design (and possibly a bottle of wine) for your newly married bestie or your charcuterie partner-in-crime to celebrate the day of love, love love.

Etsy | HandcraftedParties

Celebrate Galentine’s Day by dropping off one of these grown-up conversation heart piñatas at your best friend's door. The mini piñata comes in 10 bright colors and your choice of a classic conversation heart phrase or a custom name. Snag one in your bestie's favorite color and fill the heart with mini bottles of her go-to vino, some festive lip-gloss or home-baked cookies. Leave her goodies on her stoop as a special, socially-distance surprise for the holiday.

Etsy | SweetHooligansDesign

Refresh your home chef’s apron collection with this airy linen design. The flattering, minimalist-style silhouette and lightweight linen fabric make this apron a welcome addition to their cooking routine. Two deep pockets offer hands-free storage for phones, timers and anything else they might need while preparing their latest mouthwatering meal. Choose between a natural or white linen fabric and add customize with your Valentine’s name in your choice of 12 font styles.

From $29.92
Etsy | ScriptLeather
On Sale!

Valentine’s Day is a failproof excuse to pry your husband’s tattered leather wallet from his hands and replace it with a sensible and sentimental upgrade. The genuine leather design comes equipped with all the typical features to store his money and ID: a single money slot, five card slots and two hidden slots within a bifold design. Add polish to his wallet with your choice of six classic embossed monogram and initial designs. Want to up the ante even more? Add a custom engraved message in your own handwriting to have embossed into the interior of the wallet. Scribe a little love note, encouraging phrase or personal joke on the wallet to bring a smile to his face each day.

From $53.10
Etsy | MijMojDesign
On Sale!

This ring and watch stand marries sentimentality with streamlined design and function. The oak design is handcrafted and comes with two large columns to hold watches or bracelets and a smaller central column to store your rings. And if you really want to wow them, be sure to take advantage of the optional personalization with a custom engraved message across the wood base.


51 Best Gifts for Travelers

Here’s what to get the traveler who has everything, from decor and accessories to practical gear for their next adventure.

From $28.25
Etsy | JenSimpsonDesign

Encourage your travel partner to capture all their best memories from your travels with this beautiful journal and scrapbook. Each journal features 136 double-sided pages with 16 trip segments complete with captivating questions and free-writing areas. Better still, the journal has a page to list your favorite restaurants, bars and attractions for each trip. Customize the notebook with your friend’s name as an extra sentimental touch.

From $23.90 (Set of 6)
Etsy | TheTreatBoxBakery

Send your kiddo off to school with something extra-sweet for their teacher. This customizable cookie includes six scrumptious brown sugar cookies dressed to impress with royal icing. Bonus: The Treat Box Bakery offers vegan, gluten-free, vegan/gluten-free and regular cookies to accommodate dietary restrictions. Stick to the simple sugar flavor or up the ante with one of the additional 21 flavors, including almond, cinnamon spice, strawberry or sparkling wine.

Etsy | SpaAlchemy

If you’re uncertain about what to get your tween for V-Day, we’ve got you covered. This oversized conversation heart bath bomb is bound to be a hit. The sweetheart bombs are sold solo and come in four classic phrases: Be Mine, Kiss Me, XOXO or I Love You. The spa-worthy bombs smell like the real thing and come infused with skin-loving ingredients like almond oil for a decadent bath experience. And our favorite part? Each bomb features a surprise interior color, making the fizzing experience even more exciting.

Our 38 Favorite Skincare Products Under $25

Shop the affordable skincare buys we use and highly recommend.

Shop More Gift Ideas

Next Up

34 Valentine's Day Gift Ideas Under $25

Saying "I love you" doesn't have to be expensive. Spoil your favorite person with these budget-friendly Valentine's Day gifts.

The Best Last-Minute Valentine's Day Gift Ideas

Down to the wire? Here are our favorite flowers, cards, candy and more.

32 Fun + Affordable Valentine's Day Gift Ideas for Kids

Save the cards and candy for class, and surprise your kiddo with a little something off this list.

20 Valentine's Day Cards for Everyone on Your List

Looking for a pretty (or punny) way to express your love this Valentine's Day? One of these cards might be exactly what you're looking for.

25 Best Mother's Day Gifts on Etsy

May brings flowers and a time to celebrate all the moms in our village. Shower them with these handmade and personalized gifts.

84 Best Father's Day Gifts You Can Get on Amazon

Show the dads in your life the love they deserve with a thoughtful gift, no matter their interests or your budget.

The Best Gifts Under $20 to Buy in Bulk

Whether you're buying for your family or a big group, just about anyone will love these unconventional, affordable and thoughtful gifts.

36 Best Gift Ideas for Every Kind of Camper

From backcountry breakfasts to alpine treks, we've got all the essentials for stocking stuffers and wishlist gifts for your favorite campers.

26 Best Gardening Gifts for Mother's Day

From lavish to low-cost, surprise Mom with one of these garden-inspired gift picks.

The Best Toys for 9-Year-Olds

It's their last year of single digits! Make the most of it with these creative and entertaining gifts chosen specifically for our active, fun-loving tweenagers.

Go Shopping

Refresh your home with stylish products handpicked by HGTV editors.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.