Good Bones: Double Trouble in a Duplex Remodel

Mina and Karen face financial challenges when they take on a duplex-to-single-family-home conversion in a transitioning neighborhood. With some creative styling, an opened up floor plan and a few glam touches, the duo is confident that the renovated home will turn a nice profit — and help bolster the neighborhood.

Keep in mind: Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money from these affiliate links.

June 01, 2016

By: David L. Haynes

Related To:

Shop This Look

Photo By: AJ Mast/AP Images

Creative Upcycling, With Context

When Karen and Mina undertake a renovation on an old home, Karen likes to incorporate touches of the home's history in the modern design. Here Mina installs some custom wall accents in the finished kitchen of a remodeled home in the Indianapolis neighborhood known as East of State. Karen took ceiling medallions salvaged during the demolition phase of the project, then modified and repurposed them as wall art.

Gallery Opening

In this former duplex newly converted to a bright and open single-family home, Mina and Karen reconfigured entire spaces, removing walls and reworking the home's front entrance. When they put the house on the market, they not only staged the home with stylish furnishings, but had the brilliant idea of letting the open house also serve as an showing of works by a local artist. As seen here, original paintings are featured throughout the home.

Cloistered and Secluded

The master suite is located at the rear of the home for maximum privacy. Rich, dark tones and a textured accent wall give the room a luxe and opulent feel.

BEFORE

Mina and Karen purchased this boarded-up and dilapidated duplex for only $15,000. The home is located in a transitioning neighborhood just east of State Avenue in Indianapolis. "East of State" is an area adjacent to the historic and revitalizing Fountain Square neighborhood. "I feel like if Fountain Square is the frontier," says Karen, [then] East of State is the territory beyond the frontier."

AFTER

As part of the conversion to a single-family residence, the home's front porch, stairs and entrance have been substantially modified. A new front door was installed on the left side of the house and three new large windows added on the right. The porch-stair entry on the right side was filled in with new brick and the wall skim-coated for a clean, uniform look. The exterior is repainted in a bold green with white brick and trim.

BEFORE

The rear of the Woodlawn duplex prior to the renovation

Every tragic house deserves a second chance — because underneath all that mess, we might find some really good bones.

—Mina Starsiak

AFTER

Large windows were added at the rear of the home, providing a nice view onto the private back yard. A new deck makes an ideal spot for relaxing, entertaining and grilling out.

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

Mina pitches in on demo day. The Woodlawn duplex is actually the second house that Mina and Karen purchased in Indy's East of State neighborhood. "The nice thing [is that] we have one renovation two doors down," says Mina, "and that one's kind of standalone on the block. It's the only house that's renovated. So doing this second house, I think, is not only going to help the first house sell, but help people kind of buy into East of State."

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

Karen helps out with on the job site. In this transitioning area of southeast Indianapolis, the prices on homes can vary widely and easy resale is by no means guaranteed, so Mina and Karen took a bit of a risk with this venture. They had to keep repair costs low but were confident they could make the house super-attractive to buyers — and perhaps even help jumpstart more quality home renovations in the area. "Because we're starting in this new area," says Karen "we really need to set the tone. This is our flagship."

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

Mina lends a hand on exterior trim painting as part of the effort to boost the home's curb appeal. "Because prices in this neighborhood are just starting to edge up," says Mina, "we want to lure buyers in with a feeling of luxury."

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

With respect to the exterior trim, Mina corrects an earlier aesthetic "error in judgment." After trying bright yellow trim paint, then teal, she ultimately opts (despite protests from Karen) to go back to basics with a simple cream white.

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

Karen provides ample evidence that she has no fear of power tools.

BEFORE

Prior to the renovation, each unit in the duplex had a small front room just inside the front entrance.

AFTER

This dining area is part of the new open floor plan that extends across both sides of the former duplex. To achieve the structural modificaitons, a new header was added where the central load-bearing wall had been. This enabled the creation of a large, open space that incorporates the dining and living areas and kitchen. The massive header beam is made from LVL (laminated veneer lumber), a super dense and strong material capable of supporting large amounts of weight.

Dining Room, Detail

A cage chandelier creates an interesting shadow pattern on the dining room ceiling. This area uses high narrow windows to allow natural light into the space while maintaining a private feel. "What we try to do in a lot of the houses," says Mina, "[is to] have full windows facing the back, which is your pretty, private space. But on the sides, because we're in an urban area, you're usually pretty close to your neighbor, so we do high windows."

BEFORE

Like many of the homes that Karen and Mina take on, this one was in a distressed state both inside and out prior to the renovation. The total square footage is just under 1200 square feet, so each of the two duplex units was tiny. But the joists were in good shape and the structure was sound enough to withstand a major overhaul.

Living Room, AFTER

In the reconfigured spaces, the more commonareas — the living/dining room and kitchen — are all located toward the front of the house while the private spaces, the bedrooms and bathrooms, are at the rear.

Living Room, AFTER

Living Room, Detail

Felt pouf ottomans with flower petal design in neutral shades are one of the distinctive accents used in the living room.

Two Chicks and a Hammer

A literal take on Karen and Mina's company namesake makes an appearance on a throw pillow on the living room sectional.

Dinosaur Bones?

A toy dinosaur, excavated from the backyard prior to the renovation, makes its way into the new dining room decor.

Kitchen, AFTER

Prior to the renovation, each duplex unit had only a tiny, cramped kitchen. In the home's new layout, the new kitchen features plenty of room and a large serving bar that can seat up to eight. To save on costs and help make budget, Mina and Karen went with laminate flooring that emulates the look of wood.

Kitchen, AFTER

Other features in the new kitchen include ceiling height cabinets, new appliances and granite countertops and backsplash.

Kitchen, Detail

Karen salvaged the home's ceiling medallions, added some batting and burlap fabric and created these decorative wall accents that can also serve as a station to post notes or shopping lists.

Master Bedroom, AFTER

The master bedroom is done in dark tones for an elegant and masculine feel. The textured accent wall creates an impressive visual focal point.

Master Bedroom, AFTER

In the new floor plan, the master bedroom is accessed via a hallway and creates a quiet and private space. "We've designed and decorated the house," says Mina, "so when you walk in, everything outside just kind of disappears because [inside] it's just beautiful and perfect."

Karen adds: "This home is going to be someone's oasis."

Master Bedroom, AFTER

"We're going to push the envelope to give the feel of luxury finishes without breaking the bank" said Mina of the home's overall design scheme. "We're going to give it some drama in a tailored way; a little whimsy, and glamorous."

Master Bedroom, Detail

So we [put] a little bit of like 1920s art deco glamour in the back of the house. In the front, you have this really serene, very tailored, but still a little bit of sparkle. — Karen E Laine

Master Bath, AFTER

The newly renovated master bath has high windows to let in natural light, twin vanities and a soaking tub/shower with white tile in an arabesque design.

Guest Bedroom, AFTER

The center portion of the house contains a second bedroom and bath as well as a laundry closet.

Guest Bedroom, AFTER

The guest bedroom is fairly spacious, with ample closet space, a bright color palette and lots of natural light.

Guest Bath, AFTER

The guest bath can be accessed both from the guest room and the adjacent hallway.

The Woodlawn Project, Staging Day

Mina stages the newly renovated guest bath in preparation for the open house.

The Woodlawn Project, Staging Day

Following a four-week renovation, Mina and Karen add finishing touches at the Woodlawn house. Furniture arrives for staging the home just in time for the open house.

The Woodlawn Project, Staging Day

The Upshot

Karen and Mina purchased this home for just $15,000 but put $130,000 into renovating it — for a total outlay of $145,000. Within four weeks, including renovation time, they were able to sell it for $175,000 to Keaton and Deanna, a young couple who love older, historic homes. "It's an older neighborhood," says new homeowner Deanna, "and we like that feel. We like to be a part of something that's growing."

The Upshot

The best part about it," says new homeowner Deanna, "is that we could get a home that's been almost completely rebuilt, and the price is affordable. And we know in a few years, that that's going to be an investment for us."

Back Yard Deck, Detail

More from Good Bones

If you enjoyed this project, be sure to check out behind-the-scenes and before-and-after photos from the series premiere: First Look: HGTV's Good Bones, or this project: A Heroic Renovation in a Historic Indy Neighborhood.

You can also read more about Mina and Karen in this article on HGTV's design blog: 8 Reasons Why We Can't Wait for 'Good Bones' Season 2.

Good Bones

Good Bones: Double Trouble in a Duplex Remodel

Related To:

Shop This Look

Creative Upcycling, With Context

Gallery Opening

Cloistered and Secluded

BEFORE

AFTER

BEFORE

AFTER

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

The Woodlawn Project: Behind the Scenes

BEFORE

AFTER

Dining Room, Detail

BEFORE

Living Room, AFTER

Living Room, AFTER

Living Room, AFTER

Living Room, Detail

Two Chicks and a Hammer

Dinosaur Bones?

Kitchen, AFTER

Kitchen, AFTER

Kitchen, Detail

Kitchen, Detail

Master Bedroom, AFTER

Master Bedroom, AFTER

Master Bedroom, AFTER

Master Bedroom, Detail

Master Bedroom, Detail

Master Bath, AFTER

Guest Bedroom, AFTER

Guest Bedroom, AFTER

Guest Bath, AFTER

The Woodlawn Project, Staging Day

The Woodlawn Project, Staging Day

The Woodlawn Project, Staging Day

The Woodlawn Project, Staging Day

The Upshot

The Upshot

Back Yard Deck, Detail

More from Good Bones

Good Bones: The Orange Street Duplex Conversion 30 Photos

'Good Bones' Renovation Tips 5 Videos

First Look: HGTV's 'Good Bones' 39 Photos

Good Vibes Are in Abundance on HGTV's 'Good Bones'

Good Bones: A Beacon in Bates-Hendricks 33 Photos

24 Awe-Inspiring 'Good Bones' Outdoor Transformations 48 Photos

Related Pages