Halloween Party Appetizer: Cheesy Eyeballs

This fun-to-make appetizer will have your Halloween party guests doing a double take. A few simple ingredients make this savory snack a scary-easy addition to your party table.
Halloween Appetizer

Halloween Party Appetizer: Cheesy Eyeballs

This fun-to-make appetizer will have your Halloween party guests doing a double take. A few simple ingredients make this savory snack a scary-easy addition to your party table.

©Sam Henderson

Sam Henderson

Related To:

Ingredients

  • 24 mini cheese rounds
  • 24 green olive slices
  • 8 black olives
  • red gel food color
  • chopstick or skewer
  • small paintbrush

Instructions

1: Remove the wax casing from the cheeses. Use a paring knife to carefully cut a divot in the center of the cheese that's approximately the size of a green olive slice (Image 1).

2: Press a green olive slice into the divot firmly, being careful not to damage the olive slice (Image 2).

3: Use a paring knife to make three round slices from each black olive. Place the black olive round in the center of the green olive to make a "pupil." Tip: For best results, use a chopstick or skewer to push the edges of the black olive inside the green olive's center.

Halloween Cheesy Eyeballs Appetizer

Place Black Olive Into the Cheese Eyeball

Use a paring knife to make three round slices from each black olive. Place the black olive round in the center of the green olive to make a 'pupil.' Tip: For best results, use a chopstick or skewer to push the edges of the black olive inside the green olive's center.

©Sam Henderson

Sam Henderson

4: Dip a small paintbrush into the red gel food coloring and paint squiggly lines from the olives outward to give the eyes a bloodshot effect. Six to eight lines per eyeball will provide the best look.

Painting Veins With Food Coloring on Cheesy Halloween Appetizer

Paint Veins on Cheese

Dip a small paintbrush into the red gel food coloring and paint squiggly lines from the olives outward. Six to eight lines per cheesy eyeball will provide the best bloodshot effect.

©Sam Henderson

Sam Henderson

5: Keep cold until ready to serve. Serve alongside fresh veggies and your favorite crackers or pita bread for a healthy Halloween party snack.

Halloween Appetizer

Serve Cheesy Eyeballs for Halloween

Keep cold until ready to serve. Serve alongside fresh veggies and your favorite crackers or pita bread for a healthy Halloween party snack.

©Sam Henderson

Sam Henderson

Next Up

Halloween Party Recipes: Witches' Teeth and Custard Cups

Full of fall flavors, these treats are scary good!

DIY Halloween Outdoor Decor That Will Have "All Eyes on Boo"

Create some Halloween curb appeal with a mischevious monster door. Inexpensive card stock, crepe paper and tape are a budget-friendly way to deck out your home before Halloween guests or trick-or-treaters arrive.

Halloween Dessert: Marshmallow Spider Web Doughnuts

Serve up some creepy-crawly fun this Halloween with these purple candy-dipped doughnuts covered in marshmallow "webs." A spider candy mold is needed for this recipe and can be found at most well-stocked craft stores and online. You can also use ready-made gummy spiders for an easy shortcut.

10 Best Halloween Countdown Calendars

The countdown to Halloween is on! Start a fun new tradition with these festive calendars.

How to Make Foam Halloween Tombstones

These hand carved and painted tombstones are an inexpensive and easy way to create a personalized and creative outdoor Halloween display.

36 Last-Minute Halloween Costumes You Can Order Online

Are the holidays sneaking up on you? We've got you covered for the first one to hit the scene — Halloween — with costumes you can get delivered to your home in a matter of days.

10 Fun Ways to Treat Your Favorite Pup This Halloween

Halloween isn't just for humans! Show your four-legged best friend some love with these festive dog treats, toys, accessories and costumes.

Don't Miss This: Halloween Costumes Are BOGO Half-Off at Target Right Now

Dress the whole family for a night of fun with Target's latest deals on adult, kid, toddler and baby costumes.

Free, Printable Halloween Scavenger Hunts

Spirit away boredom this Halloween with our interactive, indoor and outdoor Halloween scavenger hunts you can download and print at home for free.

Make This Handheld Halloween Photo Booth

All you need is a cardboard box, some inexpensive supplies and a few Halloween decorations. Bonus: You can make this photo booth for any holiday.

More from:

Halloween Ideas

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

On TV

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.