Upcycle an Old Cutlery Box Into a New Jewelry Box

Vintage cutlery boxes are a frequent fixture at estate and yard sales — usually in pretty worn condition. With just a little elbow grease, you can refinish and re-line them for a massive upcycled jewelry box.
Upcycled Jewelry Box

Upcycled Jewelry Box

This box started out its life as a cutlery box. A yard-sale find at $9, it was refurbished into a beautiful jewelry holder.

Photo by: H. Camille Smith

H. Camille Smith

Materials Needed:

  • wooden cutlery box
  • paint stripper
  • chemical-resistant gloves
  • metal paint scraper
  • metal pan
  • pliers
  • screwdriver
  • sandpaper (coarse-, medium- and fine-grits)
  • oil-based wood stain
  • oil-based polyurethane
  • 3 disposible chip brushes
  • spray adhesive
  • scissors
  • fabric or felt for relining box
  • newspaper or dropcloth

Cutlery Box Before

Before: The old cutlery box was a steal at just $9 but the decades-old blond finish and felt-lined interior were in poor condition (Images 1 and 2).

Remove Hardware

Using the correct screwdriver — either flat or Phillips head — remove the original hardware, being careful to keep the screws with the hardware by placing everything together in a plastic bag (Images 1 and 2). Tip: A miniature screwdriver, like those typically used for repairing eyeglasses, may come in handy if your cutlery box still has the original brass plate (Image 3).

Remove Felt Liners

Using a metal paint scraper, pry the felt liner away from the sides of the box then lift out the upper tray (Images 1 and 2). Use pliers to remove the nails or staples securing the cutlery dividers to the top section's bottom which you'll need to save for re-covering in a later step (Image 3). If your box has a bottom drawer, remove its felt liner but don't discard (Image 4).

Strip Inside of Box

If the felt was held in place with glue, stripping is necessary to create a clean surface before restaining the wood. First, don chemical-resistant gloves, then pour stripper into a metal pan and use a disposable chip brush to apply a thick coat of the chemical to the glue-covered areas (Image 1). Read manufacturer's instructions to learn how long to let the stripper soften the glue (typically 15 minutes up to one hour) before removing with a metal scraper (Image 2).

Strip Outside of Box

Following the same steps listed above — don protective gloves, brush on stripper, allow stripper to soften finish, then scrape off (Images 1 and 2) — remove existing finish. Tip: Multiple applications of stripper may be necessary to completely remove the existing finish.

Sand, Stain and Apply Polyurethane

To remove any remaining bits of the previous finish and prepare the wood for the new stain, thoroughly sand the box starting with coarse-grit sandpaper then working your way down to medium- then finally fine-grit (Image 1). Using a chip brush, apply wood stain in the direction of the wood grain (Image 2). Allow stain to fully cure, following manufacturer's recommended dry time, then brush on a coat of polyurethane following the wood grain and consistently checking for drips or any lost brush bristles (Image 3).

Cover Liners

Use existing liners as a template to cut new fabric, leaving a 1/2 to 1 inch excess on all sides (Image 1). Place liner front-side-up on a dropcloth or newspaper-covered work surface; coat liner with an even layer of spray adhesive (Image 2). Lay new fabric face-down on a clean area of the work surface then center liner glue-side-down on fabric and press to secure (Image 3). Carefully spray just the edges of liner's back with adhesive (Image 4) then press edges of the fabric to secure. Cut off excess fabric with scissors to create a clean, mitred edge (Image 5).

Attach Hardware

Pop re-covered liners into box then reattach hardware (Image 1). If cutlery box had an existing brass plate, have it engraved with the jewelry box owner's initials then reattach (Image 2). Tip: Trophy suppliers and jewelry stores often offer engraving for a small fee. Note: Instead of covering another piece of cardboard to line the inside lid of the box, as I have here, have a piece of mirror cut at a local glass or hardware store (Image 3).

Keep Reading

Next Up

How-to: Hanging Jewelry Storage

The DIY experts at HGTV Magazine recreated this flea market find. Here’s how you can, too.

Turn a Plastic Storage Container Into a Mobile Toy Box

Breathe new life into a basic plastic storage bin by adding jute rope, metal casters and a colorful fabric liner.

Easy-to-Craft Handmade Jewelry Box

Turn inexpensive fence-post caps into a pretty jewelry or gift box. By itself, the box makes a thoughtful birthday, Mother's Day or holiday gift. Fill it with sweet treats or a small trinket for a handmade gift they won't soon forget.

Closet Storage Bins and Boxes

Make order out of closet chaos with affordable bins and boxes.

Transform a Wine Crate Into a Decorative Storage Box

Transform a used wine crate into a vintage-looking storage box with handles for easy transporting.

Make a Herringbone Wood Toy Box Storage Ottoman

Add designer flair to a basic wooden toy box with strips of wood, tacks and an upholstered plywood top.

How to Upcycle an Old Pallet Into Garage Storage

Turn an old pallet into a place to store tools large and small.

Upcycle Old Pallets Into Colorful Planter Boxes

Old wood pallets are a great (and often free!) source of weathered lumber – perfect for upcycling into a rustic planter box. Paint the slats in watery shades of blue and green for a beachy update.

Landscape Design Supplies and Materials

How to choose the best landscape design supplies and materials for your next residential landscaping project

Closet Storage Containers

Try a closet storage container to corral clutter instantly.

Shop This Look

Found a living space you love in HGTV's Photo Library? Get the look in your own home with products from Wayfair.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.