Carrot Flop: There’s a Beta-Carotene Deficiency in My Garden!

Carrots are a finicky crop and among the most difficult vegetables to grow. Here are some tips that will help.
Carrot Plants

Carrot Plants

Whether you grow traditional orange carrots, or raise a rainbow of purple, red, white and red varieties, these crunchy, colorful veggies are fun to raise and good for you. Carrots need deep, loose soil, and when they aren’t happy in the garden, their roots become stunted, twisted or forked.

Photo by: Shutterstock/Lukas Gojda

Shutterstock/Lukas Gojda

Q: I have a lot of trouble growing carrots. Do you have any tips?


You are not alone. Carrots are a finicky crop and among the most difficult vegetables to grow. Wooden, stunted and misshapen little pencils are the norm for many gardeners regardless of location, climate or experience. The following are a few tips that I hope will give you renewed confidence to try again next year.

Consider the Soil

Like all root crops, carrots do best in loamy soil with a touch of sandiness. They suffer and grow gnarly and deformed -- or worse still don’t grow at all -- when there are obstructions of any kind, most notably rocks or hard compaction. Most of us aren’t blessed with this golden combination of loamy sand. But amending with lots and lots of homemade compost just before planting time each year can make a big difference. However, in the case of impenetrable compacted ground or clay soil that is impossible to dig into or amend, your best bet is to build a deep raised bed on top and sow into that.

When and How to Sow

Sowing too early is a common mistake. Carrots are slow to germinate, but they are even slower and sometimes won’t sprout at all if the soil  temperatures are too low. Roughly 70-75°F is ideal. I suggest sowing seeds two weeks before the last frost date. Add new seeds over the course of several weeks to stagger the harvest and avoid a rush of carrots all at one time. Since the tiny seeds are sown only ½” deep, it is essential to keep the soil moist through the long germination period. They will die if the top layer dries out or crusts over.

Protect the Seeds

I have trouble with digging squirrels in my garden. They always seem to follow after me and dig up any freshly tilled or sown soil, ruining my hard work and disrupting seed growth in the process. Over time I have learned to cover the bed with a row cover, netting or chicken wire immediately after sowing. Don’t forget to remove the protection once tiny leaves appear.

Keep the Soil Moist

Carrots grow wooden and thin during droughts. You’ll turn out a happy crop if you can manage to keep the soil consistently moist but not soggy right through the growing season. Amending with compost will help create soil that is well draining yet retains moisture well.

The Heat Is On

Carrots do not like excessively hot soil. The bed should not be mulched after sowing as this can impede germination; however, a light sprinkling of grass clippings mid-season, once the crop is underway can offer the soil some protection from the summer sun’s hot rays. If summer is brutal in your area, you can try covering the bed with a light row cover to deflect some heat.

Growing in Pots

This is doable, believe it or not, as long as you can manage to keep the soil moist. The good news is you don’t have to battle with rocks or poor soil. Choose a nice, deep pot: 12-inches deep is ideal. Grow a short, half-sized variety. I’ve had incredible success in a big bucket with a cute, but tough little carrot called ‘Paris Market.’ Kids love it!

Garden authority Gayla Trail is the creator of

Next Up

How Do You Know When Carrots Are Ready to Harvest?

Size, color and timing are all factors that determine when to pick your garden carrots.

3 Ways to Store and Preserve Fresh-Picked Carrots

Enjoy the flavor of garden-fresh carrots all year long by learning how to freeze, pressure cook and store them properly.

How to Grow Carrots

The secret to growing beautiful carrots is in the soil. Follow these tips to start your carrot patch off on the right foot.

Veggies You Can Plant in Mid-Summer

There are several fast-growing summer vegetables and herbs that can still be planted in July and August.

What's the Difference Between a Yam and a Sweet Potato?

These two veggies are often called the same thing or misidentified; find out how to tell the difference between these two tasty tubers.

What Are the Different Types of Carrots?

Learn about the five types of carrots and which ones will work best for your garden.

Companion Plants for Carrots

Carrots are one of the trickiest, but most rewarding, vegetables to grow at home. Try companion planting techniques for a more successful carrot crop this year.

Planting and Growing Turnips

Turnips are easy to grow and so delicious. Learn how to plant and grow this versatile vegetable.

Are Beets a Vegetable?

Yes, they are, but did you also know that beets can be used to make red velvet cake and that beet greens are just as nutritious as the beet itself? Learn more interesting facts about this colorful veggie.

The Best Veggies and Herbs to Grow Indoors

A robust vegetable garden can be grown indoors all year long. Find out what edibles thrive indoors and get tips on planting, as well as finding the right space and lighting.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.


Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.