My Very Own, First-Ever Kitchen Reno

Sara Peterson, HGTV Magazine's Editor in chief, opens up about her complete kitchen overhaul.

Photo by: Michael Edwards

Michael Edwards

Related To:

A year and a half after buying my house — a three-bedroom, two-bathroom rancher — I’m ready to gut reno my kitchen.

I bought my 2,000-square-foot house from a 91-year-old woman who built it in 1996. It was obvious she loved the place and took excellent care of it. I was especially surprised at how tidy and clean the kitchen was when I moved in. The white porcelain sink was scratched and the fridge made a lot of gurgling sounds, but that was about it. Plus she had carefully saved every manual for all the appliances, and she kept a thorough record of every repair job she'd had done and every maintenance appointment she had made. This cooking space was spotless. It was in perfect working order. But, unfortunately, it was 100% not my style.

Sara_s Beach House

Sara_s Beach House

The kitchen before the renovation started.

Photo by: Philip Friedman

Philip Friedman

The kitchen before the renovation started.

So I decided to get rid of everything in it: the orangey faux-terra-cotta floor tiles. All the white appliances. The sink and faucet. The green “marble” Formica countertops. And the oak cabinets.

It’s not easy for me to chuck things that still technically work (I ended up donating most of the stuff, including all the cabinets, to charity). I’m Midwestern and, generally speaking, most people just don’t do that in the Midwest. If something’s working, you don’t get rid of it. Period. End of story. That’s how I grew up, and, as they say, you can take the girl out of Nebraska, but you can’t take Nebraska out of the girl.

At the same time, I have never been more ready for my own total kitchen redo. I have lived in several houses but had never done a whole-hog kitchen overhaul before. I have also spent the better part of my magazine career (20 years and counting) looking at other people’s remodeled kitchens — styling them, photographing them and writing about them. Now it’s my turn.

Sara_s Beach House

Sara_s Beach House

The kitchen before the renovation started.

Photo by: Philip Friedman

Philip Friedman

The kitchen before the renovation started.

The first thing I did was hire a trustworthy contractor. He came highly recommended by a friend who has been working with him for more than 13 years. She invites him to family events. We’ll call him Jim. 

The next thing I did was pick out materials and go over and over and over and over and over them with Jim. I can’t stress enough how important it is to go over and over and over and over every single thing before ordering anything. Also, I don’t trust myself to do any kind of kitchen math, even simple kitchen math, so Jim does all the calculating and measuring.

So far I’ve decided on:

Next on my list of things to shop for:

  • a sink
  • a faucet
  • cabinet hardware
  • a pendant to go above the sink
  • barstools 

Check back soon to see what I decide on next!

Keep Reading

Next Up

I Married My Contractor!

When Susan Laney bought her Savannah fixer-upper, she knew it was a great match. She didn't realize then that it was also a great matchmaker!

Sara Peterson's Kitchen Redo: What Goes on the Floor?

Sara Peterson, HGTV Magazine's Editor in chief, opens up about choosing the tile for her complete kitchen overhaul.

Starting a Kitchen Renovation

Get tips for choosing professionals and hiring contractors for your project

From Desperate Kitchens to Kitchens of Distinction

John and Anthony bring the special sauce to another fine batch of kitchen makeovers in HGTV's inspirational-transformational kitchen show, America's Most Desperate Kitchens.

10 Incredible Kitchen Makeovers From Fixer Upper

Missing Chip and JoJo? We've got your Fixer Upper fix.

Historic Kitchen Renovation

Designer Bryan Reiss created a stunning and functional kitchen space during this renovation, while also preserving many of its original historic elements.

Compact Doesn't Mean Confined Kitchen

Homeowner and designers team up to create an open kitchen floor plan using color and materials.

9 Reasons You'll Love 'My Flippin' Friends'

These hardworking Milwaukee pals make the Central Perk crew look like a bunch of slackers.

10 Lessons From a 'Young House Love' Kitchen Reno

Even seasoned home improvers can learn new tricks! Take it from Young House Love’s John and Sherry Petersik, who aced this major makeover. HGTV Magazine takes you inside.

A Colorful Cook Space: The Facelift That Made This Kitchen Look 10 Years Younger

HGTV Magazine chronicles a Nevada family who gave their boring kitchen an unforgettable makeover.Keep in mind: Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money from these links.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.