Air Filters for Allergy Sufferers

What devices work best to help keep our space allergen-free?
Close-up of household air filter


Close-up of household air filter

Photo by: Jupiterimages


There are many products on the market that claim to reduce or cure allergies due to indoor-air-quality problems. We see commercials on TV and ads in magazine touting household appliances that use electricity to clean the air in small areas of rooms. However, these devices are very expensive and they do in fact only clean the air in a limited (less-than-room-size) space.

So is there an effective way to keep indoor air as allergen-free as possible? Yes, in fact, there are several, ranging from pretty darn expensive to very reasonable. Let's take a look at them:

Whole-house electronic air cleaners do the same job at a relative fraction of the cost of some of the room-size units, and they’ve been on the market for years (but not as well-advertised).

The nice thing about whole-house electronic air cleaners is that no particle is too small to be captured by them, so they can collect bacteria and mold spores? And even smoke! However, they require a standard household air filter to be mounted ahead of them to catch larger particles, and it's best to keep the furnace fan running all the time so the filter is constantly cleaning the air.

The downside of electronic air cleaners is that they may snap with an electrical discharge when they are dirty, they create small amounts of ozone (the "clean smell" that advertisers like to brag about), and they don't remove vapors or odors from the air. Also, they see a rapid falloff in efficiency as they get dirty, so regular cleaning is important. And they should be installed when the home is being built, since they are difficult and expensive to install after the furnace or air-handler is in place.

Some gimmick air cleaners claim to be electronic, but most work poorly if at all. A true electronic air cleaner requires electric power and is usually at least 4 inches thick. (We often hear people touting "electrostatic" air cleaners as a less-expensive alternative to the electronic types. They fit into standard air-filter holders, and they require no electric power. The idea is that they develop a static charge from the air, which may work somewhat during the winter when there’s a lot of static charge in the air, but what about in summer, when mold and pollen are most active?)

An "almost HEPA" air filter is a good alternative to an electronic air cleaner. These 4-inch-thick pleated filters do almost as good a job as electronic air cleaners. They filter more over a longer period of time, since their efficiency remains high even after they get dirty. They don't snap, crackle or pop, they don’t create ozone and they don’t require a pre-filter.

But on the down side, they have to be replaced every three months, and they are much more expensive than standard filters. Due to their size, these filter systems also are best installed along with the furnace.

An activated-charcoal filter is the only solution if the allergy sufferer is bothered by odors or chemicals. Activated charcoal and certain other man-made substances can absorb both, but there has to be sufficient depth to the product to do much absorbing. I've seen gimmicky air filters with charcoal grains placed here and there, but I doubt that they do any good. Something that will remove odors and chemicals must be filled at least an inch thick, and, since these devices aren’t made to remove dust, dander and spores, they require pre-filters.

Some more good news about activated-charcoal filters, though: They are very durable, because the charcoal can be reactivated several times by baking it. That means that they don't have to be replaced nearly as often. The upshot is that if your client has allergies, you can offer help. Work with a knowledgeable HVAC professional to provide the most effective and cost-effective solution.

Next Up

Why Is There so Much Dust in My House?

Find the answers to frequently asked cleaning questions, plus get 10 handy tips for making your house less dusty.

10 Ways to Manage the Hair in Your House

When vacuums and brooms aren't enough, try these tips for picking up all that hair around your home.

18 Products That Help Relieve Seasonal Allergies

Shop our favorite natural product picks that will help defeat seasonal allergy symptoms.

The 8 Best Air Purifiers of 2024, Tested and Reviewed

Breathe deeper in your home by adding a top-rated air purifier that reduces dust, mold, pet dander, smoke and odor.

Allergy-Proof Your Home

6 tips for clearing your indoor air

Low-Pollen Houseplants

Allergic to your indoor plants? Try these sneeze-free varieties.

Ways to Improve Indoor Air Quality

Follow these easy tips to refresh and recharge your home this spring.

Mold Allergy Symptoms

Kiss itchy skin rashes, watery eyes and sneezing goodbye with this guide for identifying and treating mold allergy symptoms.

The Benefits of Whole-Home Air Cleaners

Improve indoor air quality with no- and low-ozone systems.

Cleaning Indoor Air With Plants

Remove carbon monoxide and other pollutants with toxin-absorbing species.

Go Shopping

Get product recommendations from HGTV editors, plus can’t-miss sales and deals.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.