Planting Heirloom Tomatoes

Cultivate these delicious vintage varieties of tomatoes in your garden.
Related To:
Garden Basket of Vegetables

Garden Basket of Vegetables

A variety of vegetables are collected in this garden basket. Learn how to cultivate these vintage and delicious varieties of tomatoes in your garden.

From artichokes to zucchini, heirloom vegetables have become trendy, and heirloom tomatoes in particular are getting most of the attention. According to master gardener Paul James, the reason is simple: "Heirloom tomatoes often taste much better than their hybridized cousins."

An heirloom plant is one that has been open-pollinated; it hasn't been hybridized, and as a result, it grows true from a seed. Its ancestry must be traceable back to at least 50 years, and it must have some sort of history, although it doesn't really seem to matter whether its history is well documented or based largely on folklore.

In this heirloom-tomato garden there are 26 varieties, each with a distinctive flavor, and in many cases, a very interesting past.

'Brandywine' is one of the best-tasting tomatoes of all time, Paul says. "It's an Amish variety whose roots can be traced all the way back to 1885. Of course, it's almost certainly much older than that, but that's as far as heirloom historians can trace it."

Heirloom Tomato Varieties

See All Photos

Cherokee Purple Tomato

The Cherokee Purple Tomato features lush, sweet fruit and a rich purple color.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds

'Gold Medal'

First listed as ‘Ruby Gold’ in a 1921 seed catalog, this sweet tomato was renamed ‘Gold Medal’ around 1976. The yellow skins have reddish-pink markings, and the yellow meat inside shows a faint blush. Ready in about 75 day, this tomato has a low acid content that gives it a mild taste

Photo By: Image courtesy of Seed Savers Exchange

Aunt Ruby's german green

Aunt Ruby's German Green is one of the largest green beefsteak tomatoes and can grow to over one pound.

Halladay's 'Mortgage Lifter'

Many gardeners claim to grow the legendary ‘Mortgage Lifter’. According to the story, the plants were so popular, the original grower sold enough of them to pay off the mortgage on his family farm. This heirloom hails from the James Halladay family in Kentucky, where it’s been grown since the 1930s. The pink beefsteak fruits are meaty and rich in old-fashioned tomato taste.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Seed Savers Exchange

Pilcer Vesy

A productive plant that yields plenty of large, lemon-yellow tomatoes with thick, tasty flesh these Pilcer Vesy beauties are originally from Russia and are sure to become a favorite here.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds

'Black from Tula'

A slightly salty, smoky flavor distinguishes this Russian heirloom from Tula, an industrial city south of Moscow. The fruits vary from dark brownish-purple to purple-black and can weigh up to 14 ounces. They ripen mid-season on indeterminate vines and are good sliced or canned.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Seed Savers Exchange

'Amish Paste'

The succulent 'Amish Paste' heirloom tomato features juicy, meaty flesh and, naturally, makes for an excellent sauce.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Seed Savers Exchange

'Jaune Flamme'

This French heirloom’s name means “yellow flame.” The apricot-colored fruits have a sweet flavor with a hint of tartness and are ready to harvest early in the season. Tomatoes hang in clusters on indeterminate vines; each fruit weighs about 3 to 4 ounces.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Burpee

Cour Di Bue

A fabulous Oxhert-type heirloom with a sweet, delicious taste, this tomato is one of Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds owner Jere Gettle’s favorites—he calls the flavor “perfect.”

Photo By: Image courtesy of Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds

'Orange Roma'

Dating back to around 1955, these early-yielding orange tomatoes have very few seeds and a sweet, fruity flavor. The thick, meaty flesh cooks down nicely for making pastes and sauces. The indeterminate vines bear prolifically.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Burpee

Great White Tomato

Creamy white fruit and a subtle fruity flavor distinguish the Great White tomato.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds.

'San Marzano'

Italy is home to these deep red, plum-type tomatoes, and San Marzanos grown in the rich soil of the Campania region are said to be among the world’s best paste types. Their sweet flavor, dense pulp, low acidity, and low seed count make them ideal for homemade sauces and pizzas. The bright red skins are easy to peel.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Burpee

'Mr. Stripey'

Weighing in around one to two pounds at maturity, ‘Mr. Stripey’ is a beefsteak-type tomato with pinkish-red and yellow streaks, and a high sugar content that makes them sweet and delicious. The indeterminate vines start bearing in about 80 days and reach 8 to 10 feet tall.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Burpee


A huge, brilliant yellow tomato marbled with red, the Hillbilly looks beautiful sliced, and impresses with a rich, sweet flavor.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds

'Brandywine Pink'

From 1885, this Amish heirloom has a tangy, rich tomato flavor. The rosy pink fruits are beefsteak-sized, produced on indeterminate vines with leaves that resemble a potato plant’s foliage. The fruits ripen late in the season and are held in small clusters.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Burpee

Woodle Orange tomato

The eye-popping color of the Woodle Orange heirloom tomato.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Seed Savers Exchange

Heirloom Violet Jasper

The heirloom Violet Jasper boasts beautiful iridescent green streaks.

Photo By: Image courtesy of Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds

Another interesting tomato is 'Caspian Pink', so named because it's native to an area near the Caspian Sea and because it's pink. According to Paul, this tomato is meaty and very flavorful.

'Pineapple' bears hefty (sometimes up to two pounds) tomatoes with a mild flavor that's almost tropical-fruity-sweet. 'Nebraska Wedding' is an old favorite largely because it marries a near perfect balance of sweetness and acidity.

Because heirloom vegetables haven't been hybridized, they may be more susceptible to disease. "But what they lack in terms of disease resistance," Paul says, "they more than make up for in terms of what matters most - flavor."

Keep Reading

Next Up

How to Plant Bare-Root Vegetables

Discover the best way to plant asparagus, rhubarb and strawberries in your garden.

How to Sow and Plant Fruiting Vegetables

Large leaves, golden flowers and heavy yields make squashes, zucchini and cucumbers ideal plants for productive pots.

How to Turn a Tomato Cage Into a Plant Stand

Tomato cages aren’t just for tomatoes. Upcycle a tomato cage to a modern, unique planter for anywhere in your home, inside or out.

The 10 Essential Steps to Planting Perennials

Get your perennials off to a solid start and they’ll reward you with many seasons of color.

Family Planting: The Giant Garden

Large plants that dwarf little people can be a wonderful addition to a children’s garden.

How to Plant Evergreens in Containers

Learn how to properly plant evergreens in containers to keep color alive in your garden all year around.

Planting Annuals: When and How To Plant Annual Flowers

Learn the ins and outs of planting annuals, including when to plant annuals and techniques you can use to boost success.

1,000+ Photos

Browse beautiful photos of our favorite outdoor spaces: decks, patios, porches and more.


Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.