A Key Lime Treat

Key lime pie has gone from hometown treasure to coast-to-coast favorite.
By: Linda Gordon
Related To:
Key Lime Pie Dessert

Key Lime Pie Dessert

Key lime pie - made with South Florida Key limes, of course - has gone from hometown treasure to coast-to-coast favorite.

The feather-light texture and pleasing sweet-tart flavor make it a popular dessert in both white-linen-tablecloth establishments and neighborhood pubs almost anywhere the limes (or bottles of Key lime juice) are available.

While some call for fresh eggs and others substitute frozen whipped topping or cream cheese - grated lime and cream of tartar sometimes appear as options - the right juice and Eagle Brand Sweetened Condensed Milk are the cornerstones of a proper Key lime pie. Those garden-variety supermarket Persian limes don't produce the same result, and Eagle is the undisputed brand of choice among professional chefs as well as home cooks. Eagle Family Foods, in fact, is the company that introduced the product in 1856.

According to legend, about 75 years it made its way to remote South Florida when a shipment of the stuff was sent to the cook who fed crews building the Overseas Highway connecting Florida's mainland with the Keys during the Depression. The cook mixed it with juice from the small yellow limes that flourished locally, and a dessert masterpiece was born.

Naples attorney Larry Ingram's best-liked recipe was handed down by his mother, who took it off the side of a can of Eagle Brand Sweetened Condensed Milk years ago. He picks the limes off a tree in his yard.

"With this particular recipe you can make the pie in the traditional way by not adding in more than a 'glop' of the beaten egg whites," he says. "On the other hand, if you like a lighter pie - more like a chiffon filling - you can add more of the beaten egg whites to the egg yolk/condensed milk mixture."

Key Lime Pie I

Ingredients:

4 eggs
1/2-cup Key lime juice
1 can Eagle Brand Sweetened Condensed Milk
8 Tbsp. sugar
1/4-tsp. cream of tartar
1 tsp. vanilla extract
1 prepared pie shell (regular or graham cracker)

Preparation:

Separate egg yolks from egg whites. Mix can of sweetened condensed milk with egg yolks. Mix Key lime juice with egg yolks and sweetened condensed milk. Gently fold a spoonful or two of meringue (recipe follows) into mixture. (The more meringue you add, the lighter and fluffier the pie filling will be.)

Pour into pre-baked or graham-cracker pie shell.

To make meringue, add cream of tartar to egg whites. Then add vanilla extract. Beat egg whites until mixture begins to foam. Slowly add sugar while continuing to beat egg whites. Beat egg whites until whites stand in "peaks" in beating bowl.

Cover egg mixture in pie shell with meringue and bake in preheated 350-degree oven for 12 to 15 minutes or until meringue is lightly browned.

- Courtesy of Larry Ingram, Naples, Fla.

Key Lime Pie II

Ingredients:

1 can Eagle Brand Sweetened Condensed Milk
12-ounce container Cool Whip
6 ounces Key lime juice, strained if necessary
1 large graham-cracker pie crust

Preparation:

Mix first three ingredients together. Pour into prepared crust. Some people recommend freezing the pie for 24 hours before serving. Others suggest placing the finished product in the refrigerator for a minimum of four hours.

Note: Nancy Stewart uses four packages (2.1 ounces each) of frozen mini phyllo dough shells in place of a traditional crust. After spooning the pie mixture into the shells, refrigerate the tarts for at least an hour or two. Garnish with raspberries and mint.

- Courtesy of Mrs. Frank White, Eileen Casali, Joan Gokey and Nancy Stewart, all of Naples

Keep Reading

Next Up

Make Boozy, Oven-Baked S'mores for a Grown-Up Treat

These spiked s'mores are just the thing for cool-weather hangouts — with or without a campfire.

7 Summer Throwback Desserts With a Twist

Whip up the perfect summertime dessert for your next gathering with a twist on these tried-and-true favorites.

Make an Easy, Homemade Caramel Dip With Only 3 Ingredients

Whip up this decadent caramel dip using just three simple ingredients. Your sweet tooth will thank you.

Try This Island-Inspired Twist on a Classic: Pineapple Creme Brulee Recipe

Served in a freshly sliced pineapple and gently torched to perfection, this pineapple crème brulee is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Lemon-Lavender Tea Cake Recipe

Serve up the perfect spring dessert with tiny bundt cakes drizzled in a lemon glaze and sprinkled with loose lavender.

Homemade Candy Cane Recipe

You'll twist and shout with the holiday spirit after making homemade candy canes.

Chocolate of the Gods Mousse with Raspberries and Mint

Impress your guests with this rich recipe that's sure to be a crowd pleaser.

Tropical Banana Pudding in-a-Jar Recipe

Toasted coconut and a personal, portable presentation take this favorite summertime dessert to the next level.

Neapolitan Bonbon Cupcakes Recipe

Fancy chocolates make a festive topping for these Neapolitan cupcakes. For an extra-special gift, use your sweetheart's favorite variety to finish off these treats.

Martha Washington Candy Recipe

This old-fashioned confection is a rich mixture of sugar, butter and pecans rolled into a ball of bittersweet dark chocolate.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.