Penthouse 101: The History Behind the Pricey Real Estate

Once undesirable, penthouses are now some of the most expensive properties on the market.

By: Emily Nonko
Manhattan Penthouse

Manhattan Penthouse

A duplex penthouse atop the Baccarat Hotel & Residence, in Midtown Manhattan.

Photo by: Halstead

Halstead

There’s perhaps a no more extravagant experience than scaling a skyscraper and exiting the elevator into a palatial, top-floor penthouse. These apartments, considered the crown jewels of any apartment tower, have a unique history that dates to 1920s New York. Today, the penthouse accounts for an entire sector of the luxury real estate market, reserved for a select group of residents who prefer their palaces sky-high. From New York to Los Angeles, it’s the kind of property that requires just the right buyer willing to pay prices as high as their apartments.

History

Penthouse Exterior

Penthouse Exterior

The outside of 100 Barclay in New York City.

Photo by: Ty Cole

Ty Cole

The idea of a penthouse apartment was born in the 1920s, the decade known as the roaring twenties. Economic growth brought a construction boom to New York City and there was a high demand for living in cities. New Yorkers were packing into apartment buildings, initially with no desire to live on top of them. In fact, before the ‘20s New York City rooftops looked pretty bleak: pipes snaked between water towers and chimneys spewed dark soot. The tops of buildings were actually reserved for servant’s quarters, poorly-insulated clapboard structures often built illegally and intended to remain out of sight.

Newly-built luxury apartments around Central Park began to advertise more formal servant penthouses as a building amenity. But as apartments grew taller, fashionable New Yorkers developed a new taste for the amazing views that came with. In a change of preference, these residents evicted their servants in order to illegally sublet the penthouses upstairs. In 1925, the city changed the laws to fully legalize penthouse living, and the rest is history.

Marketing the Penthouse

Manhattan Penthouse

Manhattan Penthouse

A duplex penthouse atop the Baccarat Hotel & Residence, in Midtown Manhattan.

Photo by: Halstead

Halstead

As New Yorkers began considering the top floors of buildings desirable real estate, developers seized on the opportunity. They marketed penthouse apartments at premium prices, billing them as homes right in the heart of the city, still far above the noise and crowds of urban life. And they catered to the New York elite.

One of the first luxury penthouses designed atop a building was for cereal heiress Marjorie Merriweather Post – and it proved developers had the ability to build mansions in the sky. In 1925, the George Fuller Construction Company wanted to develop a 14-story apartment house on the site of Post Hutton’s mansion. She agreed, only if Fuller recreated much of her 54-room home on the building’s top three floors. The resulting penthouse boasted a wrap-around terrace on its highest floor, 12 wood-burning fireplaces, 17 bathrooms, two kitchens, a wood-paneled dining room large enough to invite 125 guests for a formal sit-down meal, a bakery, cold-storage room for flowers and furs, wine room, pair of coat rooms (one for the ladies, the other for gentlemen), gown closet, sun porches (one for sleeping) and a playroom.

The Modern-Day Penthouse

100 Barclay Penthouse

100 Barclay Penthouse

The top two floors of the world's first Art Deco skyscraper can be purchased for $59 million.

Photo by: Scott Frances

Scott Frances

These days, penthouse designs fall short of Marjorie Merriweather Post’s palace. But buildings have gotten taller, meaning that the views from top-floor pads have only gotten more impressive. According to Corcoran agent Scott Stewart – now marketing the penthouse at the Upper East Side development 20 East End Avenue – the penthouse refers to the top floor unit of any tall residential building. “They could be cream of the crop or they could be run of the mill,” he says. But in new, luxury developments, the space is still considered the showpiece of the building, often priced highest out of all the units. “In the luxury market, these are often full-floor units, with incredible ceiling height, large windows and views,” Stewart says.

The Penthouse Buyer

Chicago Penthouse

Chicago Penthouse

The upper floors of the former Montgomery Ward's Observatory have been converted into a $4.975 penthouse unit.

Photo by: The Skowron Group

The Skowron Group

Given that these apartments are priced into the multi-millions, “it’s a rare buyer,” Stewart says. Deep-pocketed apartment hunters looking for outdoor space are often drawn to penthouses, given that the setback design of many of these apartments allows for private terraces. Accomplished musicians, Stewart notes, enjoy the fact that there aren’t apartments above them to disturb. And finally, international buyers looking for trophy properties around the world prefer the upper floors. Agents will go to great lengths to show off penthouse properties, hosting luxe events and parties to lure buyers with picky, refined tastes. “These are buyers with the luxury of not having to make an immediate decision,” Stewart says. “They are really waiting for that special penthouse that checks off 99 percent of their boxes to make them happy.”

Now on the Market

Manhattan Penthouse

Manhattan Penthouse

A duplex penthouse atop the Baccarat Hotel & Residence, in Midtown Manhattan.

Photo by: Halstead

Halstead

So what’s out there on the market when it comes to penthouse units? In New York, one of the most expensive homes now for sale is the penthouse apartment atop 432 Park Avenue, the tallest residential tower in the country. With sweeping views of the city, it’s asking a whopping $82 million. The top two floors of the world's first Art Deco skyscraper, 100 Barclay, are also up for grabs, asking $59 million. And the duplex penthouse atop the Baccarat Hotel & Residence, in Midtown Manhattan, is a relative deal at $39.9 million.

LEVEL Penthouse in Los Angeles

LEVEL Penthouse in Los Angeles

You can rent out the top-floor duplex penthouse for a cool $100,000 per month.

Photo by: Hunter Kerhart

Hunter Kerhart

Penthouses, of course, aren’t limited to New York City. In Chicago, the upper floors of the former Montgomery Ward's Observatory have been converted into the $4.975 million penthouse unit, boasting views of the city skyline to Lake Michigan. At the new Downtown Los Angeles tower Level Furnished Living, you can rent out the top-floor duplex penthouse (complete with 13-foot floor-to-ceiling windows) for a cool $100,000 per month.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Elegant Penthouse Redesign

Designer Michael Abrams transforms a Chicago penthouse to mirror the magnificent views outside.

Penthouse Remodel in Downtown St. Louis

A St. Louis family consolidated four apartments into a single penthouse home. S&K Interiors designed the remodel while construction was going on.

Old World-Inspired Estate

A Houston estate has a minimalist, unique aesthetic highlighted by architectural details. Designer Marie Flanigan embraced Old World, rustic and contemporary furnishings, accessories and artwork to create a truly singular -- and beautiful -- home.

Stylish Miami Estate Shines Thanks to Artful Touches

Design firm DKOR delivered for a family that loves to entertain family and friends. A new, open floor plan created better flow throughout, unique lighting emphasizes the high ceilings, while the homeowners' art collection adds color and personality to the home.

6 Real-Life Vacation Rentals Inspired by Award-Worthy Movies

With a little imagination, these gorgeous homes appear to be ripped right from the big screen.

8 Waterfront Homes We Can't Believe Are Actually Real RN

Infinity pools? Ocean views? Is this a dream or is it HGTV's Ultimate House Hunt?

25 Biggest Real Estate Mistakes

Get insider secrets to avoid costly blunders on the most important investment of your life.

Design Budgeting 101: Outdoor Rooms

Professional designers know how to stretch a buck. Joan Grabel and Katie Z. Leavy share some of their best ideas for decorating an outdoor space for less.

Ask the Producer: Behind the Scenes at Beach Flip

Go behind the scenes of HGTV's hottest summer show.

Modern Penthouse Remodel

Designer Andreas Charalambous helps a Washington, D.C., penthouse apartment reach its full potential with a gorgeous open floor plan and custom modern details.

On TV

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.