What are Zigbee and Z-Wave for Home Automation?
Are you considering a home automation system to control things like heating and cooling, security, outdoor sprinkler systems and more? If so, you'll want to learn about some of the wireless technologies available to control the system and allow the various components to communicate with one another. Two of the most popular home automation system wireless technologies are ZigBee and Z-Wave. Both products offer distinct advantages and disadvantages, which might make one or the other the right choice for your home automation system.
When the HVAC system in Jeff Wilson's 70-year-old Cape Cod home broke five years ago, well before his Deep Energy Retrofit (DER) efforts, he used the opportunity to upgrade the old unit to a system that is 97 percent efficient. With other efficiency measures, including insulation and new windows, his energy bills will eventually be two-thirds less.
Jeff shopped around before settling on this Bryant air conditioner with a Seasonal Energy Efficiency Rating (SEER) of 16. (The higher the number, the more efficient the system.) This unit works in concert with the 97-percent-efficient furnace with the variable-speed blower that allows Jeff to set the humidity level on his thermostat. This feature reduces air conditioning usage.
Here, Jeff outlines the features and benefits of the Bryant HVAC system he chose for his home. Those include: an efficient, maintenance-free motor; variable-speed control to adjust air flow based on the season and manage humidity; an easy-to-replace filter; a pre-filter that captures airborne particles; and greater heat return to the home in winter for efficient air filtering.
Jeff's furnace capacity is perfectly sized for his home, which is important to maximize the efficiency of the system. "If the system kicks on and cools down the house in five minutes, that sounds like a good thing — but the compressor will burn out years before it is supposed to," he points out. Bigger is not better. Size the HVAC to the size of your home, he advises.
When home automation was first introduced in the 1960s, modern wireless technology didn't exist yet, and so homeowners who wanted to control their homes' systems remotely needed to rely on hard-wired systems like X10 and Universal Powerline Bus (UPB). These hard-wired systems plugged directly into the home's electrical system, and because of this they were susceptible to frequent performance issues related to wiring distances, signal interference or "line noise" and phase differences. When wireless technologies emerged, they quickly began to replace older, hard-wired systems. If you're new to home automation or looking to replace an existing, hard-wired system, you'll definitely want to consider a wireless standard like ZigBee or Z-Wave.
Home automation systems integrate electrical devices with each other, and the advantages of having those devices communicate with each other wirelessly cannot be understated. The range and quality of wireless signals is often greater and more reliable than that of older hard-wired systems, and other benefits like safety (no risk of a short) and ease of use are attractive as well. In terms of ZigBee and Z-Wave, these two systems offer their own distinct benefits and weaknesses.
Z-Wave was the original wireless home automation technology, and it set the standard for competitive products. Z-Wave implemented a simple but extremely important feature—it made all devices in an automation system double as signal repeaters, a failsafe which greatly increased reliability. This also greatly increased the range of the network, since if two communicating devices were far apart, intervening devices could bridge the gap. Z-Wave is also seen as the most "user friendly" home automation wireless network, with a fairly uncomplicated setup that's recommended for beginners. Z-Wave is generally seen as a more mainstream product than ZigBee.
ZigBee is viewed as more of an expert or true enthusiast's platform—it offers a more technical approach to setup and maintenance that anyone with programming or electrical engineering skills may find appealing. One of the potential issues with ZigBee is that its devices may have difficulty communicating with those made by different manufacturers.
More: Wireless Home Automation
See Also: How to Plan a Home Control System
- Home Control
- CEDIA 2012 Integrated Home Finalist: Lights, Camera, Action
- CEDIA 2012 Integrated Home Finalist: Light & Color
- CEDIA 2013 Integrated Home Finalist: Mediterranean Luxury
- CEDIA 2013 Integrated Home Finalist: Form, Function & Style
- CEDIA 2012 Integrated Home Finalist: Sleek & Sophisticated
- CEDIA 2012 Integrated Home Finalist: Mountain Escape
- CEDIA 2012 Integrated Home Finalist: Seamless Upgrade
- CEDIA 2012 Integrated Home Finalist: Distinctive Appeal
- Ask Carley: Your Questions About HGTV Smart Home 2014 Get Answered
- CEDIA 2012 Integrated Home Finalist: Clean Customization
- CEDIA 2012 Integrated Home Finalist: Ski-In Retreat