Butternut Rum Toddy Cocktail Recipe

Butternut squash? In a cocktail? Yes, please!
Butternut Rum Toddy Cocktail Recipe

Butternut Rum Toddy Cocktail Recipe

Who needs butter when you can get the same rich flavor from butternut squash?

Photo by: Image courtesy of Center Bar

Image courtesy of Center Bar

Who needs butter when you can get the same rich flavor from butternut squash?

Butternut squash isn’t just for dinner. At Center Bar in New York City, chef/owner Michael Lomonaco makes it into a syrup for a butternutty hot toddy.

Butternut Rum Toddy

Courtesy of Michael Lomonaco, chef/owner of Center Bar, New York City

  • 1 ½ ounces Ron Zacapa rum
  • 1 ounce butternut squash syrup
  • ½ ounce B&B
  • 2 dashes orange bitters
  • Boiling water
  • Macerated apple slice to garnish

Butternut Squash Syrup:

  • 1 butternut squash
  • 6 cups water
  • 4 cups light brown sugar
  • 4 cups granulated sugar
  • 2 teaspoons cinnamon or 2 cinnamon sticks

Cut butternut squash in half and roast in oven face down. After squash is roasted, cut into chunks. In a pot, add water, brown sugar, granulated sugar and the cinnamon. Boil for 15 minutes, then taste to see how potent the syrup is. It should have a nutty taste.

Add rum, butternut squash syrup, B&B and orange bitters to a hot toddy glass, then add hot water and stir.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Black Magic Halloween Cocktail Recipe

This deliciously layered cocktail blends together orange juice, triple sec and black vodka.

Witches' Brew Halloween Cocktail Recipe

Use a cauldron to mix up a batch of this party-perfect punch. A mixture of pineapple and cranberry juice gives this drink its harvest moon hue, while a shot of Malibu rum gives it a Caribbean kick.

Liquefied Ghost Cocktail Recipe

This ghostly white drink tastes like a grown-up version of a milkshake — with a kick. Mix vanilla simple syrup, cream, vodka and soda together, then serve in a martini glass.

Zombie Cocktail Recipe

Like the walking dead, this cocktail packs a powerful punch thanks to apricot brandy and three types of rum: light, dark and high-proof Bacardi 151. Grenadine and orange juice give the drink its lovely pumpkin hue.

Jack-o'-Lantern Halloween Cocktail Recipe

This orange and black cocktail uses a blend of cognac and Grand Marnier to pack an unexpected kick.

Zombie Slime Shooters Halloween Cocktail Recipe

"Blood slime" gives this fruity martini a creepy look that's perfect for Halloween gatherings.

Smoking Skulls Halloween Cocktail Recipe

Dry ice chips make this tasty bourbon shot a smoking Halloween favorite.

Blood Sucker Halloween Cocktail Recipe

This vampire-friendly cocktail uses strawberry or raspberry puree to add streams of "blood" down the sides of the glass.