Am I Really Ready to Buy a Home?

Overwhelmed by the idea of a monthly mortgage, taxes and other costs of owning a home? Do a little real estate therapy with expert Tara-Nicholle Nelson.
Mid-Century Modern Cottage With Lovely Landscape

Mid-Century Modern Cottage With Lovely Landscape

By: Tara-Nicholle Nelson

My mother used to think it strange that someone with psychology and law degrees ended upselling real estate for a living. Lately, though, she’s conceded that my background could not be more appropriate, as an ever-increasing amount of my time is devoted to what we’ve jokingly dubbed “r.e. (short for real estate) therapy.” Even apart from the market drama, buying a home often brings up lots of issues that must be navigated to have a successful outcome -- issues as diverse as the buyer’s relationships with their parents to the buyer’s relationship with their money.

The Client

I recently had a client whose buying behaviors invoked my faux-shrink skills even more than normal. She was a nurse, earning a six-figure salary and looking to buy her first home -- at the tender age of 25 years old. Income taxes were eating her alive, she was tired of renting and she’d decided that she planned to stay put in the community for at least five years and would love to continue owning the home as an investment property over the very long term.

As bright as this gal was (I mean, look who she chose as her Realtor!), she kept doing things that were obviously self-defeating to her homeownership goals. First, she wanted to only see homes listed 50-grand above her price range -- even though I showed her the stats to prove that most homes in our area were selling at or around the list price. Once she got over that, she insisted on bringing her naysaying frenemy along on our buyer’s tours -- you know, that one quasi-friend (we all have one!) who she could count on to turn her nose up at even the most perfect property. Then she kept changing her criteria -- massively. First she wanted a condo, then a single family. First one city, then another, 20 miles away.

Finally, I sat her down for some r.e. therapy and got her to confess: she was setting herself up for failure because she was overwhelmed by the prospect of committing to a home, a community, a mortgage payment and a property. Totally understandable, for someone that age.

The Workaround

Some of it was an issue of mindset. Buying a home is a very grown-up, long-term thing that a buyer shouldn’t commit to unless they are certain that they are ready. As Warren Buffett once said, “If you don’t feel comfortable owning something for 10 years, then you shouldn’t own it for 10 minutes.” If she could come to grips with this most fundamental commitment to homeownership within her own heart, I told my client, then I could help with the rest of her commitment concerns. She could, so I did!

For her valid concerns about the notorious adjusting mortgage payments she’d heard about in the news, we made sure she got a 30-year fixed rate mortgage, the payment on which would only go down, when she built up enough equity to drop the private mortgage insurance.

If you don’t feel comfortable owning something for 10 years, then you shouldn’t own it for 10 minutes.
Warren Buffett

To assuage her stress over future repairs, we found her a nearly new townhouse with an HOA responsible for the exterior maintenance of the building (walls and roof) and a long duration left on the builder warranty. We also put in place a home warranty (that she could renew year after year) to fix the vast majority of issues that would ever arise for a $50 service call fee.

To make sure nothing major was already wrong with the place and to empower her to know how to work everything in the house, we wrote an inspection contingency into the contract, then had a detailed property inspection, and the inspector gave a tutorial on all the mechanics of the place.

And to give her the time and mental space to make a reasoned, deliberate commitment, I encouraged her to use the 17-day contingency period to drive by the community at different times of day, to bring her supportive buddies and relatives by and, to spend some time just sitting in the home, coming to grips with whether she was ready to remove contingencies and make the place hers.

The Result

She ended up buying the place. And a year later, she still loves it, though I wouldn’t be surprised to hear her say that she occasionally wakes up at night and is shocked and amazed (in a good way) to remember that she owns a home!

Next Up

Are You Financially Ready to Buy an Investment Property?

Here's what you need to consider in this real estate market before shelling out for an investment property.

The Facts on Lease-to-Buy

There's more than one way to get out of your house. You can, of course, sell it outright. Or you do a lease-to-buy deal.

Buying a Home: Don't Forget These Expenses

When deciding how large a down payment you can afford, remember to leave yourself some padding.

How to Take Title When Buying With Friends

When buying a house with a friend, it's important to choose a joint tenancy title that protects you from the unforeseen. Here are your best options.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Buying a Foreclosure

Buying a foreclosed house can mean you get a great deal, but there are some things to watch out for, too.

Buying and Selling Homes With the Market

Learn how to be a savvy seller in both buyer's and seller's markets.

Urban Home Buying Tips

Real estate agents weigh in on the downtown buying process.

Take These Pointers When Buying a Second Home

Brush up on location, lifestyle and finances while searching for your retreat.

Waterfront Buying: Top 10 Tips from Agents

Before purchasing that dream home, master these tips from the experts.

Maintaining Good Credit After Buying a Home

It's important to maintain good credit even after you buy a home. Here's how to do it.

Stories We're Following

Shop This Look

Found a living space you love in HGTV's Photo Library? Get the look in your own home with products from Wayfair.

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss HGTV in your favorite social media feeds.