Dreams Vs. Reality: Straight From the Farm

O', the country mile between what urban buyers envision versus what they find!

Related To:

The most bucolic farms of all are the ones that exist in the minds of people who have never lived on farms. We’re not saying they never, ever have real-life analogues, mind you — but it’s fair to say that when We Bought the Farm’s marvellous optimists go shopping, the barn isn’t always half full. Or on the property that’s for sale. Or — but we’re getting ahead of ourselves.

Theory: All Country Homes Have Classic Style

Reality: Questionable Taste Is Everywhere

Even big-city decor has rustic touches these days, and it’s easy to understand why; everyone loves timbered ceilings, barn doors and artful distressing. Given that, honest-to-goodness country living should be effortlessly chic, right? Alas, some farmers skip alarm clocks and jolt themselves out of bed before dawn with the force of the eye-searing paint on their walls. Weird choices aren’t exclusive to urban digs.

Theory: Who Needs a Pool When You’ve Got a Pond? 

Reality: Humans Aren’t Alone in Loving Ponds

Water features are a lot of fun, but it’s important to remember that untreated, standing water often has something of a ... funk. You’re taking a dip with a whole host of microscopic buddies. (On second thought, don’t think about the word “host,” or all of the things chlorine keeps nature from introducing to pools.)

Theory: More Bang For Your Buck!

Reality: More Heating, More Cleaning, More Repairs ...

When you’re moving to the country from, say, a downtown studio, why wouldn’t you spread out over thousands upon thousands of square feet? (As one couple puts it at the end of their search, “People ask why we bought such a big house, and ... we don’t know.”) Psst: Farmhouses have fireplaces in almost every room because they’re expensive to heat, and quaint extra bedrooms don’t clean themselves. Then there’s that dreamy wraparound porch, exposed to the elements all year long ... you get the idea.

Theory: Farmhouses Are Huge

Reality: Some Farmhouses Are Huge

These days, an American man of average height is 5-foot-10 — three inches taller than American men of a century ago, the ones who built the charming old door frames on family farms all over the country. Buyers interested in original interiors should prepare to do some ducking.

Theory: Old-World Charm!

Reality: Old-Home Weird

So having an extra sleeping space on the first floor of your home isn’t quite as exciting when you don’t have to creep out of bed to milk the cows first thing in the morning. It could be the perfect place to put up guests who tend to overstay their welcome, though, no?

Theory: You’re Getting Away From It All!

Reality: The Interstate’s Kinda Right There

Homes on working farms in the 1700s tended to be built near main roads — since trundling up a long driveway in a buggy (or on horseback, or on foot) was considerably more difficult than cruising there in a truck (and “street noise” didn’t really exist). Translation: Meet your next-door neighbor, I-80.

Theory: If You’ve Got a Barn, You’re Ready for Horses

Reality: Neigh

While one could argue that big, beautiful barns look terribly sad when they’re uninhabited, dreaming of horses and living with them are two very different things. Stall maintenance, feeding and care add up to an hour’s worth of work every day, and that’s before rides, which tack on two more hours a day and should happen five days a week (per experts).

Theory: You MUST Have Chickens

Reality: Actually, Chickens Are Pretty Great

Chickens need a clean, safe place to live and regular care and exercise, just like larger, more cinematic farm animals, but they’re comparatively easy for hobby (and young) farmers to tend, since they require just four square feet of coop space per hen and will eat almost anything (seriously, keep an eye on your shoelaces).

Tune in for an all-new episode of We Bought the Farm Saturday, June 3 at 11p|10c.

Keep Reading

Next Up

See How This Dairy Farm Bathhouse Makes Extra Space for Guests

Designer Heidi Richardson turned a 260-square-foot bathhouse into a guest cottage that suits the “family camp” environment of the surrounding dairy farm.

Face Off: New England Cape Cod Vs. Atlanta Bungalow

Forget Patriots and Falcons, we’re interested in who wins this architectural battle.

Sneak Peek: 'Brother vs. Brother' Goes to Galveston

Jonathan and Drew dive into their most challenging competition yet: waterfront homes.

'Listed Sisters' Lex and Alana Make Home Dreams a Reality

Nashville is the setting for HGTV's newest renovation series featuring a dynamic duo who help clients on their quest to find an ideal home.

Tour + Enter Now: HGTV Dream Home 2016

Browse every amazing space in HGTV Dream Home 2016, a coastal retreat in Florida, then enter for your chance to win, twice daily from today through February 18.

'Home Town': Porch Dreams for an Artist

Ben and Erin Napier of Home Town help a returning artist, with a penchant for front porches, find and create a picture-perfect home.

What's Your Lottery Dream Home? 12 Places We'll Be Moving With Our Winnings

If (when?) you pick those magic winning numbers, where would you live? We're dreaming of our favorite spots, just in time for the new HGTV series 'My Lottery Dream Home.'

Take a Peek Inside This Stunning, Fully-Stocked Party Barn

Architectural designer Kevin Transue transformed an ordinary utility barn into a stunning, fully-stocked entertainment space complete with a state-of-the-art wet bar, full catering kitchen and many more drool-worthy amenities.

5 Things Every 'Fixer Upper'-Inspired Farmhouse Bathroom Needs

Love Joanna's farmhouse-style baths? Here's how to bring 'Fixer Upper' style to your home.

Before and After: Renovating an 1841 Farmhouse

See how this historic Southern home was lovingly renovated.

Meet the Team

Get to know the talented writers and editors of HGTV's show and design blog. 

Go Behind the Blog

From the Archives

Take a look back at our past posts, from entertaining and design trends to up-and-coming HGTV shows.  

Read All Our Past Posts