How to Host the Perfect Big Game Potluck

What's a football party without food?

Related To:

The Big Game is quickly approaching. For some, that means a really great football game; for others, it means a really great excuse to throw a party. And still yet for others, it means both a really great football game and a really great excuse to throw a party.

If you fall into that last category, you probably don’t want to spend your entire day prepping, cooking and cleaning, but you probably don’t mind dedicating some time to hosting duties — as long as you can relax and enjoy the game, too. Enter, the age-old potluck dinner.

The Big Game is the perfect opportunity to host a potluck. It’s casual but fun, and guests can get creative with their dishes. If you’re unsure how to get started, look no further. I’m breaking down exactly how to host a football potluck — and how to pull it off without a glitch.

 1: PICK THE MAIN COURSE

Commit to cooking the main course, and ask guests to fill in sides, appetizers and desserts. Invite friends as early as possible, and send out an online sign-up sheet to avoid duplicate dishes. Be sure to include your main course on the sign-up sheet, so guests can plan accordingly. Consider one of these tasty main course options:

 Chili

Slow Cooker Texas Brisket Chili

Slow Cooker Texas Brisket Chili

Chili is a slow cooker fall favorite.

Searching for an easy, low-maintenance main course? Whip up a batch of chili in your slow-cooker, and you’re all set.

 Mini Burgers

Super Bowl party buffet table

Super Bowl party buffet table

Creative and inexpensive decorating ideas for your Super Bowl buffet table

Photo by: Sam Henderson

Sam Henderson

Nothing beats a burger on game day. Make them mini so guests have plenty of room to try all the food.

 Meatball Marinara Dippers

Photo by: George Foreman Grills

George Foreman Grills

This delicious meatball recipe gives you the option of using ground beef, veal or pork, so you can cater the dish to your guests’ preferences.

 Barbecue Chicken Sandwiches

Rotisserie Chicken Trick

Rotisserie Chicken Trick

Need to serve your guests protein-packed sandwiches, but don’t have the time or skill set to cook something up from scratch? Pick up a rotisserie chicken from the supermarket; then pull it apart and serve it as barbecue chicken sandwiches or sliders.

Looking to save money and time? Use a rotisserie chicken and store-bought barbecue sauce to create tasty barbecue sandwiches.

 Rosemary Smoked Chicken Wings

super bowl 2014 1

super bowl 2014 1

Fresh rosemary and garlic give these smoked wings plenty of kick. 

Photo by: Image by Anjali Pinto

Image by Anjali Pinto

Fresh rosemary, garlic and lemon juice take these chicken wings to the next level.

 2: SET UP A DRINK STATION

Whether you have a bar, a bar cart or some unused counter space, create a station dedicated to drinks. This is totally customizable depending on your and your guests’ preferences.

Photo by: Marc Kelly

Marc Kelly

Beer is a super-simple option that’s totally appropriate for a football game. Simply fill a large tub with ice and a variety of bottled beer. Set out glasses and garnishes.

 3: MAKE A CENTERPIECE

Create your own DIY centerpiece to ensure your dining (or coffee) table feels festive. Try one of these DIY centerpiece ideas:

 Football Field

Cover a small cardboard box in brown cork scrapbook paper, and fill it with artificial wheat grass. Complete your centerpiece with a miniature football and a small chalkboard sign. 

 Football Terra-Cotta Pot

Use a paint pen and a terra-cotta pot to create football-like centerpieces. Fill with flowers of your choice.

 Vintage Trophy

Fill a vintage trophy with paper shred in your team’s colors, and top it with a coordinating spray-painted football.

 Team Color Vases

Use balloons in your team’s colors for this project. Cut off the neck of a balloon, and stretch it around the bottom of a small vase. Repeat with each vase, and fill them with your favorite blooms.

 Football Pinata

Buy or make a football pinata, and display it atop synthetic turf on a cake stand. Accent the pinata with candies or noisemakers in your team’s colors.

 4: DECORATE, BUT KEEP IT SIMPLE

Decorate for your potluck with football and team-inspired decor, but aim to keep it simple. Guests will be most interested in your TV, so there’s no need to spend loads of money and time on decorations. Try one of our easy decorating ideas:

 Football Field Table Runner

Casual Football Party Table

Casual Football Party Table

Photo by: Debroah Whitlaw Llewellyn

Debroah Whitlaw Llewellyn

Use green paper and chalk to create a football field-inspired runner for your snack table.

 Football-Themed Cups and Plates

Stock Up on Disposable Cups and Plates

Stock Up on Disposable Cups and Plates

Score! These are a great deal. Football 16-ounce plastic cups, $8 for a set of 50, orientaltrading.com; Creative Converting Tail Gate Rush 9"-diameter paper plates, $3.50 for a set of 8, partyatlewis.com

Photo by: Merko Metzinger/Studio D

Merko Metzinger/Studio D

Buy disposable cups and plates themed to match the party. This inexpensive option will provide a touch of decor while also making cleanup a breeze.

 Penalty Flag Napkins

Put Napkins in a Penalty Flag Bucket

Put Napkins in a Penalty Flag Bucket

Use 3/4"-wide black electrical tape to make stripes on a white metal bucket. Design a sign on your computer, or print out our template (at hgtv.com/super-bowl-party) on thick paper, and tape it to the bucket. Fill with yellow paper napkins.

Photo by: Marko Metzinger/Studio D

Marko Metzinger/Studio D

Make stripes on a white metal bucket with 3/4-inch-wide black electrical tape. Print out our penalty flag sign on thick paper, and tape it to the bucket. Fill with yellow napkins.

 Football Paper Lanterns

Buy a pack of football paper lanterns, and attach tissue paper tassels to the bottom. Hang your lanterns anywhere that needs a festive touch.

 5: FILL IN ANY MISSING DISHES

A day or two before the party, check the online sign-up sheet to see what guests are bringing. If there are any large gaps in the menu, make a last-minute run to the grocery store, and prepare an extra dish or two. (It’s also a good idea to have easy snacks on hand, just in case food runs out — think pretzels or chips and dip.) Try one of our recipes to complete your menu:

 If You're Lacking in Desserts:

Cookie Butter Football Dip 00:57

Add some fun to your football party table with our quick and easy cookie butter football dip.

 If You're Lacking in Appetizers:

3 Delicious Tailgate Dips 01:12

Serve up these three tailgate dips and score a home run with your guests.

30 Favorite Game-Day Recipes

See All Photos
Keep football fans fueled up with these recipes for mouthwatering dips, sliders and more.

Nacho-Stuffed Potato Skins

Trade in the tortilla chips for restaurant-style potato skins topped with all the good stuff: guacamole, sour cream, scallions, cheese, bacon and more. (And guacamole does not cost extra.) Get the recipe.

Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza Hand Pies

We all know that pizza's a crowd-pleasing food that can disappear in seconds. These hearty hand pies are a perfect accompaniment to other bite-size party snacks. And they're simple to make, too. Get the recipe.

Pub-Style Pretzels and Beer Cheese

Nothing goes better together than pretzels with beer cheese and your favorite ice-cold brew. Get the recipe for both.

Meatball Marinara Dippers

Use bamboo toothpicks to serve these filling marinara meatballs. Get the recipe.

Photo By: George Foreman Grills

Peanut Butter Marshmallow Dip

Peanut butter and marshmallow fluff make the perfect dessert or appetizer dip. Serve with graham or animal crackers. Get the recipe.

Bacon and Ranch Cajun Baby Cheeseburgers

A cheeseburger is perfect for any occasion. Whip up these mini versions with Cajun seasoning, ranch and bacon for a zesty kick. Get the recipe.

Pimento Cheese

Expecting an entire fan section in your living room? Serve up this Southern-style pimento cheese that can feed at least 20 people. Get the recipe.

Photo By: Photo courtesy of Blackberry Farm and Beall + Thomas Photography

Potato Salad

Whether you're headed to a summer picnic or a Super Bowl party, you can't go wrong with a batch of homemade potato salad in tow. Get the recipe.

Queso Fundido

Bring meat, seafood and vegetarian lovers together with these twists on classic fundido dips. Get the recipes (three!).

Photo By: Jennifer Jane

Rotisserie Chicken

For a quick crowd-pleasing food that won't bust the budget or your time, pick up a rotisserie chicken from the supermarket; then pull it apart and serve it as barbecue chicken sandwiches or sliders.

Salted Stout Caramel Popcorn

Soothe anxious fans with a bottomless bowl of this crunchy-meets-salty snack. Get the recipe.

Healthy Buffalo Cauliflower Skewers

Keep your health-conscious guests in mind when planning your menu, and serve this spicy dish. Get the recipe.

Photo By: George Foreman Grills

Crostini With Herbed Cream Cheese Spread

For the perfect mix of sweet and savory, spread an herbed cream cheese on toasted baguette slices and garnish with dried fruits. Get the recipe.

Mexican Beer + Spices

Mexican beer partners with a handful of spicy sauces to create the best complement to chips and salsa. Get the recipe.

Beer-Glazed Bratswursts

Grab a lager from the pack to flavor bratwursts. Add Dijon mustard and honey, and grill them for a perfect portable treat. Sub a hot dog bun for a freshly-grilled baguette. Get the recipe.

Photo By: George Foreman Grills

Deviled Eggs, Three Ways

Deviled eggs are a classic party appetizer, but we've taken inspiration from favorite flavor combinations to put a new spin on the expected. BLT? Yup. Pesto? You know it. Get the recipes (three!).

Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich

You don't have to be from Philly to enjoy this staple sandwich. Make this with store-bought ingredients to save you time. Get the recipe.

Chile and Lime Roasted Cashews

Too much yelling at the TV? These tangy cashews will quiet the room. Get the recipe.

Gourmet Potato Chips

Help guests satisfy their salty tooth with a serve-yourself snack station stocked with kettle chips, savory seasonings and gourmet toppings. Get the how-to.

Photo By: Flynnside Out Productions

Grilled Parmesan Pesto Chicken Wings

Your guests may not agree on what team to root for, but they'll all agree this healthy version of wings is worth cheering for. Get the recipe.

Photo By: George Foreman Grills

Cornbread-Topped Chili in-a-Jar

Cornbread muffins, your favorite chili recipe, sour cream, cheese (duh!) and green onions are all you need to make this warm and cozy winning dish. Get the recipe.

Photo By: Flynnside Out Productions

Creamy Lump Crab and Corn Dip

Skip the store-bought dips and impress guests with this creamy lump crab and corn mixture served hot with toasted crostini. Get the recipe.

Grilled Sausage and Pepper Quesadillas

Throw sausage and peppers on the grill along with your burgers to make cheesy, easy-to-eat quesadillas. Get the recipe.

Photo By: George Foreman Grills

Roasted Pepper and Mozzarella Bites

If you just found out you're hosting the Super Bowl at your house, fear not. Three major ingredients create one delicious and good-looking appetizer in a jiff. Get the recipe.

Creamy Macaroni and Cheese

I don't trust anyone that doesn't like cheese. This bubbling dish calls for a combination of three tasty cheeses — white Cheddar, Gruyère and Swiss — making this mac 'n' cheese a creamy comfort food that's destined to become the center of attention at your next game. Get the recipe.

Ropa Vieja Mini Tacos

The only thing better than tacos are miniature tacos. Prep the fillings ahead of time, then assemble them in the shell right before guests arrive. Get the recipe.

Coca-Cola Cupcake With Salted Peanut Butter Frosting

Satisfy their sweet tooth during the halftime show with chocolate cupcakes flavored with Coca-Cola and salted peanut butter frosting. Get the recipe.

Triple Chocolate Brownies

Balance all those savory flavors with a touch of sweetness. These triple chocolate brownies will be the perfect treat for your armchair athlete. Get the recipe.

Barbecue Pulled Pork Quesadilla

If you have slow-cooked pork or chicken, spread it between two tortillas with cheese, spinach, barbecue sauce and salsa. Get the recipe.

Spicy Maple Salmon

The combination of hot sauce and maple syrup will take your salmon game up a notch. Make the marinade the night before to save time on game day. Get the recipe.

©George Foreman Grills

Keep Reading

Next Up

Score Big With These Game-Winning Party Ideas

Skip the chip and dips on Sunday, and score big with these football-inspired party ideas.

150+ Ways to Up This Year's Halloween Party Game

Halloween party season is upon us! Conjure up a spellbinding soiree with our tricks and treats.

Fun (and Free!) Games for Your Oscar Party

You and your guests can play along during the awards show with these printable scorecards and bingo. 

12 Places to Buy Trendy Party Supplies Online

Stock up, and celebrate for no reason at all.

How to Make Holiday Cocktail Party Invitations

Set the mood for your holiday cocktail party with a glitzy invitation. Start with our printable template, then add sparkling embellishments.

Meet the Team

Get to know the talented writers and editors of HGTV's show and design blog. 

Go Behind the Blog

From the Archives

Take a look back at our past posts, from entertaining and design trends to up-and-coming HGTV shows.  

Read All Our Past Posts